Events

(Update) Absa Cape Epic: Evans and Knox penalised for unfair advantage

· By Press Office · 426 comments

The race for the Absa African jersey took a dramatic turn Thursday when Kevin Evans and Max Knox (FedGroup Itec) were given a one-hour penalty for taking an illegal shortcut.

They had been leading the race for the special jersey – for the first all-African team in the Absa Cape Epic – after Thursday’s 88km stage four, but other riders complained after Evans apparently took a short cut across an uphill switchback.

The Commissaires Panel said in a statement that a protest had been made to the race office: “… it was stated that a member of team 13 (Kevin Evans) deviated from the course (took a shortcut) and in doing so gained an unfair advantage over other riders.

“Review of Go-Pro camera footage from the rider immediately behind the rider in question, as well as footage from team 13’s own Go-Pro (attached to the bicycle of the accused rider) confirms that the incident occurred, and that an unfair advantage was gained.”

Evans and Knox were apparently planning to appeal the sanction, but if it stands it means they would be fifth in the race for the distinctive red jersey and nearly 50 minutes behind. With only three stages to go, this would put them out of the race.

Scott Factory Racing’s Matthys Beukes and Gert Heyns inherited the category lead after FedGroup Itec were penalised. Their overall time is 19:51.09,2, with Erik Kleinhans and Nico Bell (RECM) just five minutes back.

The top all-South African team in the women’s category remains sixth-placed Yolande de Villiers and Ischen Stopforth (SasolRacing), but best local bet for a podium is third-placed Theresa Ralph, riding with Swede Jennie Stenerhag.

Thursday also saw local Definitive Bikes pairing Shan Wilson and Adrian Enthoven’s chances of winning the Master’s category suffer a setback when they were finally overhauled by Dutchman Bart Brentjens and Brazil’s Abraao Azevedo (BETCH.nl Superior Meerendal). The foreigners won the stage in 4:04.32,0 – nearly eight minutes ahead of the South Africans on the day – and are now nearly four minutes ahead overall.

South African television personality and much-decorated rider Andre Mclean continued to dominate the Grand Masters category with Austrian teammate Heinz Zoerweg (CycleLab Toyota) and are now nearly an hour ahead of Doug Brown and Switzerland’s Barti Bucher (Meerendal Songo Specialized 4).

South Africa’s hopes of a win in the mixed category were dashed by the withdrawal Thursday with breathing problems of Cherise Stander, riding with Theo Blignaut for RECM Mixed, but Cape Town’s Nizaam Essa and his Austrian partner Christina Kollman had moved up to third by the end of Thursday’s stage. Stander and Blignaut had been lying second.

Update (28 March 2014) – From the Absa Cape Epic

An appeal by Kevin Evans and Max Knox (FedGroup Itec) against their one-hour penalty for taking an illegal shortcut in the Absa Cape Epic failed Thursdaynight.

The penalty effectively ended their pursuit of the red Africa jersey – for the first all-African team to finish – and they appeared to be taking it easy on Friday’s stage five.

Other riders complained after Evans apparently took a short cut across an uphill switchback on stage four.

The Commissaires Panel said in a statement that a protest had been made to the race office: “… it was stated that a member of team 13 (Kevin Evans) deviated from the course (took a shortcut) and in doing so gained an unfair advantage over other riders.

“Review of Go-Pro camera footage from the rider immediately behind the rider in question, as well as footage from team 13’s own Go-Pro (attached to the bicycle of the accused rider) confirms that the incident occurred, and that an unfair advantage was gained.”

Video footage of the incident

Related posts

Comments

Tractor

Mar 27, 2014, 3:53 PM

The article says the decision was based on Go-Pro footage and that they will be appealing the decision. Kevin has been riding for long enough not to make a silly mistake like this, hopefully they will be found "innocent"

Sworks20

Mar 27, 2014, 4:02 PM

Fedgroup strike again.....

MTB_Roadie

Mar 27, 2014, 4:02 PM

The article says the decision was based on Go-Pro footage and that they will be appealing the decision. Kevin has been riding for long enough not to make a silly mistake like this, hopefully they will be found "innocent"

 

Why should he be found innocent? If you guilty of taking short cuts then pay the price...why should the rest cycle the full distance and they get the opportunity to cut some of it out?

GoLefty!!

Mar 27, 2014, 4:05 PM

I find this strange as during the prologue I think it was Either team Bulls or Meerendal Songo Specialised that also cut a switchback. The move could have saved them 2 seconds and it was televised yet no protest.

Rapunzel

Mar 27, 2014, 4:09 PM

would be interesting to know how many meters and seconds were saved in the shortcut because Sauser also took a shortcut through the s-bends before mineshaft at the prologue.

Danger Dassie

Mar 27, 2014, 4:09 PM

Apparently was held up by some Outcast riders on singletrack and had to get around them.

GoLefty!!

Mar 27, 2014, 4:11 PM

If thats the case then the punishment does not befit the crime.

 

But I guess the 2nd place team wants to win really badly

Tractor

Mar 27, 2014, 4:26 PM

Why should he be found innocent? If you guilty of taking short cuts then pay the price...why should the rest cycle the full distance and they get the opportunity to cut some of it out?

 

Evans has been racing at the very top end of MTB for so many years that I doubt he'll do something like that without a reason - he's well aware of the consequences, he's riding with a Go-Pro mounted, the team is appealing. Maybe just me but it just doesn't add up?

MTB_Roadie

Mar 27, 2014, 4:28 PM

Brandon Stewart today got handed a R150 000 fine for handing the team bottles when he isn't allowed to be involved with the team. I heard this news from the race village.

Sworks20

Mar 27, 2014, 4:37 PM

Evans has been racing at the very top end of MTB for so many years that I doubt he'll do something like that without a reason - he's well aware of the consequences, he's riding with a Go-Pro mounted, the team is appealing. Maybe just me but it just doesn't add up?

 

Lance Armstrong also raced at the top end of the sport and we all know how that went.

Sworks20

Mar 27, 2014, 4:43 PM

If thats the case then the punishment does not befit the crime.

 

But I guess the 2nd place team wants to win really badly

 

Do you know the 2nd place team appealed or put the protest in? Why would you say that is unfair? They cheated and took a short cut to save time.

 

If I was the 2nd team I would also protest just like Kevin and David used to appeal and protest anything and everything they could come up with against Burry and Sauser when they used to get their asses handed to them year after year at Epic.

Retrorider

Mar 27, 2014, 4:49 PM

If thats the case then the punishment does not befit the crime.

 

But I guess the 2nd place team wants to win really badly

 

This is an uncalled for comment. The protest was not made by the "second placed team". As I understand it the "second placed team" was well ahead of Kevin and company when this happened.

I am sure the second placed team would have preferred winning the jersey rather than inheriting it in this way. Think before posting.

 

Surely the 1st placed team also wanted to win really badly. Nothing wrong with that ..

Tractor

Mar 27, 2014, 4:51 PM

 

Lance Armstrong also raced at the top end of the sport and we all know how that went.

 

Huge difference between doping and lying to hide it for so many years and cutting an s-bend!

 

The article suggests that Go-Pro footage from the team behind them and Evans' own footage was used, I would guess the appeal would rest on why he did it, obviously he can't say he didn't do it. The punishment really might not fit the crime, we'll have to wait and see

DJR

Mar 27, 2014, 4:53 PM

Brandon Stewart today got handed a R150 000 fine for handing the team bottles when he isn't allowed to be involved with the team. I heard this news from the race village.

 

A hundred and fifty thousand bucks fine? Really? That's steep! For touching an untouchable bottle! Better not skip a red robot anywhere on the route! ;)

GoLefty!!

Mar 27, 2014, 4:56 PM

OUCH!!! thats even more BS

Sworks20

Mar 27, 2014, 5:02 PM

Huge difference between doping and lying to hide it for so many years and cutting an s-bend!

 

The article suggests that Go-Pro footage from the team behind them and Evans' own footage was used, I would guess the appeal would rest on why he did it, obviously he can't say he didn't do it. The punishment really might not fit the crime, we'll have to wait and see

 

2 camera's including his own as you said showed they took a shortcut and gained advantage. Not much more to be said. Maybe Fedgroup has another TUE for the shortcut but hasnt been approved by shortcuts anonymous?

 

“Review of Go-Pro camera footage from the rider immediately behind the rider in question, as well as footage from team 13’s own Go-Pro (attached to the bicycle of the accused rider) confirms that the incident occurred, and that an unfair advantage was gained.”

Guest Karma

Mar 27, 2014, 5:04 PM

OUCH!!! thats even more BS

 

If it's against Epic rules why is it BS?

So many experts and analysts on the Hub.

GoLefty!!

Mar 27, 2014, 5:06 PM

 

Do you know the 2nd place team appealed or put the protest in? Why would you say that is unfair? They cheated and took a short cut to save time.

 

If I was the 2nd team I would also protest just like Kevin and David used to appeal and protest anything and everything they could come up with against Burry and Sauser when they used to get their asses handed to them year after year at Epic.

 

 

How do you know the intent was to save or gain time? How about just needing to pass people where there is little or no space? Seems like you have a lot of sour grapes against Kevin here.

GoLefty!!

Mar 27, 2014, 5:08 PM

If it's against Epic rules why is it BS?

So many experts and analysts on the Hub.

 

R150,000 for touching a water bottle is a little stupid don't you think.

 

Sort of like a R150,000 speeding fine for doing 140 in a 120 zone

 

punishment befitting the crime??

Sworks20

Mar 27, 2014, 5:08 PM

How do you know the intent was to save or gain time? How about just needing to pass people where there is little or no space? Seems like you have a lot of sour grapes against Kevin here.

 

How do you know it wasnt?? Seems like you a fanboy of Kevin here.

Cellar

Mar 27, 2014, 5:08 PM

 

2 camera's including his own as you said showed they took a shortcut and gained advantage. Not much more to be said. Maybe Fedgroup has another TUE for the shortcut but hasnt been approved by shortcuts anonymous?

 

“Review of Go-Pro camera footage from the rider immediately behind the rider in question, as well as footage from team 13’s own Go-Pro (attached to the bicycle of the accused rider) confirms that the incident occurred, and that an unfair advantage was gained.”

 

How much time did they gain as a result of all this?

 

Has anyone seen this footage?

Sworks20

Mar 27, 2014, 5:09 PM

R150,000 for touching a water bottle is a little stupid don't you think.

 

Sort of like a R150,000 speeding fine for doing 140 in a 120 zone

 

punishment befitting the crime??

 

If its in the rules then yes. Totally fitting. If not, then no.

Sworks20

Mar 27, 2014, 5:10 PM

How much time did they gain as a result of all this?

 

 

 

Nothing, they went 60min backwards.

Cellar

Mar 27, 2014, 5:11 PM

If I was the 2nd team I would also protest just like Kevin and David used to appeal and protest anything and everything they could come up with against Burry and Sauser when they used to get their asses handed to them year after year at Epic.

 

I was just thinking of all the doper inspired protests. Funny how this makes me sad to be a south african. It seems like the proper pro's don't give a **** about a minor indiscretion like with Sauser in the prologue, but the typical saffa will kill you to gain an advantage.

 

Kind of reminds me of how south africans treat each other in traffic and so on.

Add a comment

You must log in to comment