Jump to content

ArthurPTA

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    22

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  1. ArthurPTA
    JW can win the Comrades of that I have no doubt. He ran a 64 min half marathon off limited road training. He will need to focus and not get distracted by other races in the lead up. CH on the other hand has no chance she is too slow her winning time in 2017 would only have got her 5th this year. If Gerda runs Comrades instead of Olympics she can run sub 5:50 based on her up time and how comfortable it was.
  2. ArthurPTA
    SAIDS are actually pretty good there are a number of cases in the weeks pre comrades which they have caught people not big names just random podium tests at small ish races no doubt a couple will make the news in due course. The biological passport is by far the best way to catch the dopers but it's very expensive and generally only for the top performers. A university friend works for USADA and he alaways says that a red light for them is an athlete who has had a big performance but then goes on the athlete passport and then the performance over next years markedly decreases this has been happening with many Kenyan athletes a big win in a marathon then they are never seen again. The public needs confidence in results including this years Comrades I think athletes need to be honest and open about when and where they are tested which will hopefully go some way to restoring faith.
  3. ArthurPTA
  4. ArthurPTA
    No there is a process of appeal there will be nothing from SAIDS I know one who is banned from running comrades after failing a test after a race in Pretoria.
  5. ArthurPTA
  6. ArthurPTA
    It seems some top runners won't be doing Comrades.. SAIDS have been having a big sweep on testing and it appears we are in double figures who have now been suspended! Let's see who doesn't start Comrades as no names released until after the disciplinary process.
  7. ArthurPTA
    I think the men top 2 you could be correct but I am not sure Gift still has it in him to get on the podium. I think David Gatebe and Edward Mothibi have to be the guys to watch pushing the podium. The ladies is between Ann and Gerda but I think Morozova will be on the podium like last year. There will be a huge gap to the next ladies just like last year. The race tactics will be interesting to say the least Gerda's time in Oceans indicates she could break 6 hours but Ann while not having Gerda's raw speed is a serious tough nut and will be incredibly hard to beat. I will go for Gerda I think she is probably the better up runner but let's see! Sunday morning TV viewing is sorted!
  8. ArthurPTA
    I think she could get a gold but there are so many who will be fighting for them. An Irish girl is running who recently ran 2:38 a Canadian with a 2:41 English girl with 2:41 Sarah Bard, Devon Yanko, Domonika Stelmach, Charne Bosman, jenna challenor, Yolande then you include Ann,Camille,Gerda and Alexander Morozova the list is long!
  9. ArthurPTA
  10. ArthurPTA
    He will be one to watch it will depend how he is on a very hilly course. I can't see beyond Bongmusa but if he has a bad day it could be David Gatebe, Edward Mothibi perhaps even Steve Way.
  11. ArthurPTA
  12. ArthurPTA
    The ladies podium will be the same as last year Morozova Ann and Gerda. Camille is just too slow over Comrades yes she won in 2017 but there was no competition and her time was very slow for a winning time.
  13. ArthurPTA
    I think Gerda will win and break the record she looked ridiculously comfortable on Two Oceans. Irvette said she was untouchable and could have run 3:27-3:28 on the day.
  14. ArthurPTA
    Who knows very few ultra runners worldwide are in the WADA testing pool it's too much of a niche sport... in fact SA has probably the most in the testing pool. It's a worldwide problem but in SA gets brushed under the table. Just in the last year second in Comrades is a doper Second lady this year in two oceans is a doper. Last year 8th place two oceans caught doping and banned. Comrades and Oceans need to ban dopers from their races it would be a start in gaining confidence in the results.
  15. ArthurPTA
    Many do not believe the down run record is legit by any means. Doping is real in South Africa yes they catch some but the percentage is small. JW has a valid point Mr EPO as he used to be known holds the up record.
Buy & Sell Forums Events News Stolen Bikes
Latest Ads Create Ad

All Categories

Cycling Industry Jobs All Categories

Bikes

Mountain Bikes Road Bikes Electric Bikes Triathlon & Time Trial Bikes Gravel & Cyclocross Bikes Commuter Bikes Kids Bikes Track Bikes Fat Bikes Tandem Bikes BMX Bikes Vintage Bikes Unicycles All Bikes

Electric Bikes

Mountain E-Bikes Road E-Bikes Commuter E-Bikes E-bike Frames & Parts All Electric Bikes

Frames

MTB Frames Road Frames Triathlon & TT Frames Gravel & CX Frames All Frames

Components

Drivetrain (Gears) All MTB Components All Road Components MTB Groupsets Road Groupsets Forks Rear Shocks Brakes Handlebars Stems Saddles Seat Posts Dropper Seat Posts Pedals Power Meters Vintage Components All Components

Wheels & Tyres

Complete Wheels Road Bike Wheels MTB Wheels Gravel Bike Wheels Rims Hubs Road Tyres MTB Tyres Gravel Tyres All Wheels & Tyres

Accessories

Electronic Gadgets Computers & GPS Watches & Wearables Bike Racks & Trailers Indoor Trainers & Accessories Kids Seats & Carriers Hydration & Bottles Bags & Backpacks Workshop & Tools Safety & Bike Protection Nutrition & Body All Accessories

Clothing & Apparel

Shoes Helmets Eyewear Jerseys Lycra Shorts Baggy Shorts Jackets Trisuits & Wetsuits Gloves Protective Gear Other Apparel All Clothing & Apparel

Events & Services

Event Entries Accommodation & Tours Shuttles & Bike Transport Cycling Industry Jobs Bike Services & Repairs Bike Fitment, Coaching & Training Bike Rentals Other Services All Events & Services
Sell on Bike Hub
Active Topics

Forums

General The Bike Room Sponsored
New to Cycling Ask Anything What Bike to Buy?
Gear & Bikes Tech Q&A Buyers Advice New Gear Post Your Bike & Projects Bike Shops & Services Retro / Vintage Bikes
Events & Training Events Pro Cycling Training, Health & Nutrition
Riding Group Rides Routes & Trails Share your Ride & Travels Gravity Commuting Multisport
Safety & Awareness Stolen Bikes Cycling Safety Fraud Alert Lost & Found Good Causes
Off Topic Chit Chat
Create a Topic Search Forums
Tech Events & Industry News Adventure & Travel Tips & Advice Promotions View all
Upcoming Events Create Event

All Event Categories

Browse by Category Mountain Bike Gravel Road Multisport General and Industry
Browse by Province Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Free State Mpumalanga Northern Cape Western Cape Eastern Cape Limpopo North West International
Guest
Settings
    • My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings
    • Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals
    • Help Logout