Jump to content

Cape Argus - MTB vs Roadie - how much faster can I go?


georgev

Recommended Posts

Hi guys. I would appreciate a bit of advice from you seasoned roadies out there. I do all my riding on an MTB and have done 2 Argus' now because it is just such a beautiful and festive ride. Last year took off unseeded at 10am and managed to cut my way though the traffic to get 3h45 in perfect conditions. This year I got a Q batch seeding and with my Anthem X2 down to 11,2kgs with slicks, front lockout and 130psi in the rear shock managed 3h38. Most of the time I could hang on but on the straights after Smits and the fast run from Lundudno I got left for dust. Also noticed that the roadies streamed past up Chappies but not up Suikerbossie? My question is twofold - firstly, by how much could a reasonable roadbike improve my time and enjoyment on this ride and secondly, if it's worth it, what spec bike is reasonable for a guy who is going to dust it off and ride only one or two races a year? Any comments or personal experiences would be much appreciated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hard to quantify improvement.

But lots of improvement - aerodynamics, weight, rolling resistance - can be expected.

 

Be careful now...

Once you buy a roadbike, you might never wanna wander into the bushes again. :oops:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi guys. I would appreciate a bit of advice from you seasoned roadies out there. I do all my riding on an MTB and have done 2 Argus' now because it is just such a beautiful and festive ride. Last year took off unseeded at 10am and managed to cut my way though the traffic to get 3h45 in perfect conditions. This year I got a Q batch seeding and with my Anthem X2 down to 11,2kgs with slicks, front lockout and 130psi in the rear shock managed 3h38. Most of the time I could hang on but on the straights after Smits and the fast run from Lundudno I got left for dust. Also noticed that the roadies streamed past up Chappies but not up Suikerbossie? My question is twofold - firstly, by how much could a reasonable roadbike improve my time and enjoyment on this ride and secondly, if it's worth it, what spec bike is reasonable for a guy who is going to dust it off and ride only one or two races a year? Any comments or personal experiences would be much appreciated.

 

No doubt that your time will improve. I have a low spec Trek road bike that I use about 4 times a year, you do not have to spend a lot of money to get a significant improvement on your MTB time.

 

Re the difference re Chappies and S'bossie: Chappies is not as steep and on my road bike I do between 16 and 20 km/h, on Suikerbossie I do an eve of 13-14 and on the steeper incline the gearing on your MTB works better, but you will do even better on a road bike.

 

Would like to hear other opinions about me theory.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No doubt that your time will improve. I have a low spec Trek road bike that I use about 4 times a year, you do not have to spend a lot of money to get a significant improvement on your MTB time.

 

Re the difference re Chappies and S'bossie: Chappies is not as steep and on my road bike I do between 16 and 20 km/h, on Suikerbossie I do an eve of 13-14 and on the steeper incline the gearing on your MTB works better, but you will do even better on a road bike.

 

Would like to hear other opinions about me theory.

 

I tend to agree with your theory. Chappies I can do about 13-17km/h on my mountain bike and up Suikerbossie I am doing 13-15km/h. This is of course weather, feel and mood dependent. Suikerbossie is a tougher climb than Chappies.

 

Yesterday I ran out of gears on my 2x10, 29er with slicks when road descended and on the flats (my legs) and the gearing made me loose the bunch a couple of times.

 

I was hoping to do a 3:10 or thereabouts yesterday, but I felt a bit pap in places after Simons Town and I thought the wind was a bit of a factor in the morning. Got to Simons Town in 1:11 which was on track, but thought the wind conditions were a bit "strange" from Smitswinkel to Sun Valley. Anybody else think so too?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My situation is almost identical to yours, ride 11.5 months of the year on my 12.5kg mtb.

 

Only road race I ever do is the Argus for which I manage to borrow a road bike a few days before the race and get an average speed improvement of at least 3km/h

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Forgot to mention, the road bikes are not fancy at all, just something slightly above entry level

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow! If I crunch the numbers you guys suggest then if my average speed on this Argus on a MTB was 30.1km/h for a 3h38 time - and I got that up to 33km/h on a roadbike that would bring my time in to 3h20 min and at 35km/h I could be heading for 3h07. Sounding awfully tempting. Makes me wonder how many potential sub-3 diehard mountainbikers were out there bobbing and mashing away on their FS bikes with knobblies and all!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout