Calling MTB Experts - Giant Anthem X1 vs Gary Fisher HiFi Deluxe vs Santa Cruz

[Scooterza]

Hey all, I am about to step into the world of dual suspension having ridden my Merida hardtail for the last 5 years. I am on a budget of around R8K (could stretch a bit)

 

So I am weighing up a few bikes:

2009 Giant Anthem for R6.5K http://www.gumtree.co.za/cp-sports-bicycles-fitness-in-bryanston/giant-anthem-x1-544675927 These giants seem very popular and get good reviews.

 

?2009 Gary Fisher Hifi Deluxe (front shock needs a service). for R8K https://www.bikehub.co.za/classifieds/69822-gary-fisher-hifi-deluxe-19-large-26er/

 

2007 Santa Cruz Superlight for R10K https://www.bikehub.co.za/classifieds/65189-santa-cruz-superlight/ (Worried this is quite old but like getting a bike that is less commonplace)

 

Ghost Lector for R10K https://www.bikehub.co.za/classifieds/67451-carbon-ghost-lector-7400-26er-in-great-condition/ Based on the front chainring, bike has done some work.

 

 

Any thoughts or opinions on these? Should I run a mile from any?

 

I am 5'11" so on the cusp of medium/large frame. I tend to ride trail rides, single day events, riding along the spruit and northern farms - that type of thing. I do enjoy jumping (nothing hectic) and tackling the trickier technical bits.

 

Any input is appreciated. I hope to ride both shortly.

[RichieT]

Out of that lot, best value and safest purchase, and condition looks pretty fair.. is the Anthem.. IMHO

And it's suitable for your type of riding

[Scooterza]

Out of that lot, best value and safest purchase, and condition looks pretty fair.. is the Anthem.. IMHO

And it's suitable for your type of riding

Thanks Richie! Thanks for your input!

[Scooterza]

Any other comments? Really appreciate any feedback!

[Pusher]

name='RichieT' timestamp='1384933675' post='2136644']

Out of that lot, best value and safest purchase, and condition looks pretty fair.. is the Anthem.. IMHO

And it's suitable for your type of riding

[/u]

+ 1