Cassette compatability

[Jono Waddell]

This might be a dumb question, but is there any real difference between a Tiagra 10sp and 105 10sp cassette?

 

Is it worth paying double for a 105 cassette??

[Butterbean]

The construction is completely different.

 

Some say the tiara will last longest, but is the heaviest.

 

It depends what you want tho. I ride a 105 because it was cheaper than ultegra, and I wasn't too concerned about weight. My broke friend rides tiagra, cause he spends the least amount possible

 

If you're just a weekend warrior, go for tiagra.... I'll probably do that next time around....

[NotSoBigBen]

Weight and possibly only possibly durability?

[Smartie]

Most likely weight. I ride a Tiagra cassette on my Dura-Ace/Ultegra setup. Cheap and cheerful.

 

EDIT: That said, marketing plays a big role. I still run a 9-speed setup: SRAM 9-Speed chain, Tiagra 9-Speed Cassette, Dura-Ace 9-Speed front and rear derailleurs, Ultegra 10-Speed Crankset and Ultegra 10-Speed STI's and everything operates perfectly. Perfect shifting.

 

EDIT: I use a JTEK 'shift mate' to match the 10-speed STI's to the 9-Speed rear derailleur.

Edited June 22, 2014 by Smartie

[Jono Waddell]

Im not overly concerned about weight, more the cost. I need to replace cassette and chain on tri-bike (dura-ace) and road bike (105) as well as IDT wheel which is going to be an expensive exercise.

 

If they are compatable, then i think the Tiaga should do fine.

[Smartie]

Im not overly concerned about weight, more the cost. I need to replace cassette and chain on tri-bike (dura-ace) and road bike (105) as well as IDT wheel which is going to be an expensive exercise.

 

If they are compatable, then i think the Tiaga should do fine.

 

As long as the 'speed' matches, i.e 10-speed, you will be fine. You can even use a SRAM 10-speed cassette with no worries.

[Jono Waddell]

Thanks for the info