Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Also depends how bad the bug has bit? If you go new aluminium I garantee (if you get serious about riding) you will be looking for a carbon four months later. I would go with that Scott thats a great price and you get a carbon frame, you could always upgrade parts later.

 

Why? I've been on an alu frame for the last three years, and will only buy a new alu frame. Carbon is NOT an option. My next purchase will be a Cannondale CAAD(most probably a CAAD 10) frame .

Carbon adds nothing new, other the possibility of weight saving, but that at the greater risk of acracked frame from a "side" knock.

  • Replies 41
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Why? I've been on an alu frame for the last three years, and will only buy a new alu frame. Carbon is NOT an option. My next purchase will be a Cannondale CAAD(most probably a CAAD 10) frame .

Carbon adds nothing new, other the possibility of weight saving, but that at the greater risk of acracked frame from a "side" knock.

+1

I just bought a new CAAD10 to replace my old aluminium bike. IMO it's a better frame / ride than any cheap carbon frame out there, and at 1150g for my size 56 it's no heavyweight either. I'm quite happy with aluminium, especially the CAAD10 ~ great bike.

+1

I just bought a new CAAD10 to replace my old aluminium bike. IMO it's a better frame / ride than any cheap carbon frame out there, and at 1150g for my size 56 it's no heavyweight either. I'm quite happy with aluminium, especially the CAAD10 ~ great bike.

 

Ok so how much does a CAAD10 cost? Doubt wether the Scott is cheap carbon.

Edited by Ceres

Ok so how much does a CAAD10 cost? Doubt wether the Scott is cheap carbon.

Wasn't comparing it to the Scott on price, was comparing good aluminium with bad carbon.

The CAAD10 is a more expensive bike, no argument, but the point is that not all aluminium is bad.

A carbon bike with 105 for around 10k is cutting costs somewhere. The groupset is a fixed price, so it can't be there, and that only leaves one major component ~ the frame.

Goedkoop is duurkoop. Remember that when lying in hospital after the frame fails.

Wasn't comparing it to the Scott on price, was comparing good aluminium with bad carbon.

The CAAD10 is a more expensive bike, no argument, but the point is that not all aluminium is bad.

A carbon bike with 105 for around 10k is cutting costs somewhere. The groupset is a fixed price, so it can't be there, and that only leaves one major component ~ the frame.

Goedkoop is duurkoop. Remember that when lying in hospital after the frame fails.

 

 

Ok I get your point but when I said go carbon I didnt say go cheap no name carbon. For the price for that scott carbon is the way to go.

I have a chicken egg question before you buy your new bike.............

 

Does becoming a road cyclist make you an arsehole or do you have to be an arsehole to become a road cyclist?

<Troll feeder on> It depends - does posting generalisations like this make you dof, or are you dof before posting drivel like this? <Troll feeder off>

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout