dracaena Posted June 10, 2010 Share Hi, Is there a sound non-emotive reason to upgrade from 8-speed to 9-speed? (MTB) I currently have the following components: SRAM X5 8-speed shifters. Alivio Crank Alivio FD SRAM X7 RD (recent, used to be X5) I know I'll have to replace the FD, crankset, shifters and chain to upgrade. But will this be worth the expense? I DO compete in races BUT NEVER to finish in the top 20. It is an experience and not a race for me. Only reason I am considering this is to get better quality components. The Alivio and X5 are the top end of 8 speed. If i go to 9 speed I can upgrade to Saint, SLX, XT, XTR, etc. Will these expensive components last longer than the 8 speed entry level ones? I don't want to be "all the gear but no idear" Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Johan Bornman Posted June 10, 2010 Share No, there's no reason to do so. Until 8-speed cassettes are extinct, I'll ride 8-speed. 8-speed drivetrains last longer than 9 speed which lasts longer than 10-speed. And it is far, far cheaper. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dracaena Posted June 11, 2010 Share Finally a pro 8-speed person! :-) Thank you Johan, your reply has set my mind at rest. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Christopher Brunsdon Posted June 12, 2010 Share Dracena: I'm also on 8spd and was considering the move. After doing my homework I saw that all I needed to do was just change my chainset to the correct gearing I wanted. I'm going from a 48-38-28 to a 42-32-22. I do a lot of mountain goating on my daily commute and some days I just want cruise along in granny gear. I also found that replacing my cassette with a descent one made a massive difference. Also remember that you can use any "9spd" d?railleur on 8spd. But I've also decided to stick to 8spd as its the most economical option for me. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mtb_Josh Posted June 12, 2010 Share I've got 2 bikes: 1 is an 8 speed with alivio and acera components. My newer bike is 9 speed X0 all round. Obviously the X0 is a bit nicer BUT I dont even notice the difference between 8 and 9 speed gearing. Also the shifting with acera/alivio is really not that much worse than X0 if its tuned properly. Stick with 8 speed until you wear your cassette out. All you will need to change in any case is the cassette, shifters and chain. FD and crankset will be fine. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Christopher Brunsdon Posted June 13, 2010 Share Agree with you here mtb_Josh on keeping it tuned. Got a cheap floor stand for the bike and took the time and effort to learn how to set my gears. Can say that if your bike is not tuned, it dose not matter how many gears or what components you are using - its still going to suck. cbrunsdon2010-06-14 05:26:51 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dracaena Posted June 14, 2010 Share Great. Thank you for your advice, i appreciate it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flowta Posted June 14, 2010 Share You would only need to replace the shifters, chain and cassette. The Crankset and FD will be fine. As it is on my one bike I have an 8 speed cassette and an old suntour thumbshifter, works great. I have a set of new X7 shifters if you're interested for later Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BrendonMyb Posted June 14, 2010 Share i beg to differ on the crankset, I changed from 8 - 9 speed & found the small chainring too far away from the middle blade & the narrow 9spd chain then skates on top of the teeth of the small chainring & then the worst happens. because of all the skating it then splits the outer link on the chain & your chain snaps voilently or at least thats what happened to me. its an expensive excersize & only helps for a little bit more of granny if you want. I enjoy my 9spd but dont enjoy the hassles its given me to get there. youll need: 1. 9spd shifters2. 9spd derailer ( also compatible with 8 spd )3. 9spd cassette4. 9spd crankset ( small chainring is closer to middle chainring than on 8spd )5. Front derialer will work regardless - its 8 & 9 spd compatible so as you can see its quite a hefty lump on the pocket, however what ive found is that if not exactly dialled in 9 spd is a little more forgiving & doesnt skip like 8 spd as the cassette gaps are narrower than 8 spd. soooo they both have their advantages & like i said this is just what ive found out ( the hard way ) by trial & error Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Christopher Brunsdon Posted June 14, 2010 Share I see the OEM rear d?railleur is 9spd thats fitted to 8spds. But on the chainset I have the approach of you anyway have to replace it. Its not like its a component that lasts forever. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now