Jump to content

Lube or Motor oil?


mudda

Recommended Posts

here is a question:

 

Do you buy the expensive small little lubes

 

or

 

Just use a can of th best - gtx ?

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would think if you washed it, dried it and then soaked it why not... im sure these other things are all cons...

I tend to remember that my gocart`s chain thru mud and everything survived very well due to me using normal oil and back then I didnt even soak it...

Only thing is it makes a mess as it flys out the chain
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am no Chemical Engineer and what I say could be / is wrong?

 

The viscosity of oil depends on the operating temperature of that oil. So in an engine or gearbox, the optimum operating temperature is between (again a guess) 60-100 C and that's when the oil does it's work best.

 

These temperatures are not generated by your chain so therefore I would suggest you use cycling specific lubricants.

 

PLEASE IGNORE THIS POST AS I DON'T KNOW WHAT I AM SAYING!!Big%20smile

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Viscosity of an Oilis affected by temperature and you are correct in saying that Motor Engine Oils are designed for high temperature continuous use,....However :)

 

At start up the engine is stone cold and at ambient temperature and the oil is lying in the sump. So when you turn the key the starter turns the crank shaft which turns everything else like the cam shafts. The cam shaft is bone dry at this point. The oils have additives called anti wear additives which are zinc phosphate based. These adhere to the metal pats to provide that barrier to metal to metal contact. These work best at low temperature.

 

A bicycle chain works at ambient temp and is slow speed so metal to metal contact is the norm. The type of oil i very relevant here because it would need to be more viscous to prevent the metal to metal contact. Some of the Zinc Phosphate stuff would be fantastic too.

 

So yeah you can say stick to a bicycle lube, but motor engine oil has all teh right ingredients to provide adequate lubrication.

 

wax lubes seal and don't splatter the bike with oil.

liquid Lubes penetrate and clean better and if they have the zinc stuff then they provide adequate lubrication and prevent metal to metal contact.

 

any of these will work:

 

Engine Oil

Gearbox oil

hydraulic oil above ISO22

3-in-1 oil

bicycle chain oil

 

darn you could use a 000  consistency grease

 

 

Really chain lube is not rocket science

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

What are you lubing here:

 

Car

Bike

Miesie

 

 

With a meisie, a bottle of Tassies or maybe two works just as good as an expensive bottle of wine....Wink

Wink

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I dont know cos, I ran out of bike lube recently and since then I have JUST been hauling my dipstick out of my car on a regular basis and lubing my  chain with the car oil, in my opinion its all oil, how wrong can one go.

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well' date=' I dont know cos, I ran out of bike lube recently and since then I have JUST been hauling my dipstick out of my car on a regular basis and lubing my  chain with the car oil, in my opinion its all oil, how wrong can one go.

 
[/quote']

 

 

Eish!!

 

Rather go to a garage and dumpster-dive for an "empty" can of oil and use that. Your car's dipstick should ideally not be exposed to grit. You don't want to touch the chain and introduce grit into the sump.

 

Perhaps I'm stating the obvious. In all other respects, sump oil is fine.
Johan Bornman2009-03-20 06:29:10
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well' date=' I dont know cos, I ran out of bike lube recently and since then I have JUST been hauling my dipstick out of my car on a regular basis and lubing my  chain with the car oil, in my opinion its all oil, how wrong can one go.

 
[/quote']

 

 

Eish!!

 

Rather go to a garage and dumpster-dive for an "empty" can of oil and use that. Your dipstick...and your car's dipstick should ideally not be exposed to grit. You don't want to touch the chain and introduce grit into the sump.

 

Perhaps I'm stating the obvious. In all other respects, sump oil is fine.

 

I guess as long as you let it 'drip' on it's OK then .... LOL
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ja, but dipsticks don't drip much. You'll have to remove and replace it 112 (the average no of links in a chain)  times before your chain is oiled. By number 74 you'll be so tempted to touch and release more oil.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

in fact, filtered sump oil works a treat too. Next time your car goes for a service, ask them to drain about 1L into an old oil container (take one with you).

 

When you get home take a sheet of newspaper and roll  it/ fold it into a cone.

Place this cone in a plastic bucket of sorts (preferably nothing the wife will use again ) and slowly pour the oil into the newspaper cone. The paper will filter much of the grit and the oil will be ready for use as bicycle chain lube oil.

 

The newspaper on the other hand should be disposed of properly or let it dry and use it as fire starters for your next braai.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oh yeah to lube the chain simply dunk the whole thing in the lube oil, swirl (don't drip on the floor please) and remove it. Now let it hang with the lube oil container underneath so the excess can drain back into the container.

 

cheap and eco friendly. Recycling is a practice that should be rewarded.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lefty, with respect, this is crazy. Who wants to handle old oil? I also doubt that the newspaper will filter the oil in under ten days. By then the dog has pushed over the bucket and.......

 

Why do these oil threads always go downhill?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout