Jump to content

Can this be repaired?


Vetseun

Recommended Posts

As I stopped at our front gate after my ride this morning I suddenly heard a loud crack sound from my bikes frame. I discovered that the rear chainstay / swingarm has snapped off.

The bike is a FELT Edict 29er dual.post-16512-0-60471100-1395594888_thumb.jpg

 

Now my three questions:

 

1) Can an engineering works that specialises in aluminium welding be able to repair/ weld?

 

2) Warantee claim? Problem is that the bike was brought from the USA. It was a gift, thus no proof of payment.

 

3) Will I be able to purchase the swing arm from local Felt suppliers and who sells this brand in SA?

 

Shot

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Felt have left SA. Possibly try contact Felt on their www. Possibly buy new arm. Or lbs could source for you. Don't weld, I did with my old Cannondalde, kept breaking.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ouch......and biting my fingers to not make a smart ass comment.

 

Alu welding will work.....problem is finding someone that can do it properly. Maybe have a look at the guys building off-road aluminium trailers.

 

Hope you get sorted

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My personal opinion,rather replace the swing arm if possible,because the following scenarios may come to play

-That may be a weakpoint on your frame if repaired,and may possibly break again,and you may get injured.

-You may always doubt the integrity of the repair,and instead of concentrating fully on technique and trail,the repaired area will always be on your mind,thus holding you back.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As jy nie regkom met n nuwe swingarm of iets nie.Ek het laas jaar Junie by Fabrinox in die Paarl gewerk, dis 'n ent vanaf die Vrystaat, maar die ouens wat daar werk kan baie goed sweis. En ek weet in my tyd daar het die een ou baie met aliminium gewerk so hulle is baie goed. So ek dink dit kan geen skade maak om te bel en uit te vind of hulle vir jou kan help nie.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As jy nie regkom met n nuwe swingarm of iets nie.Ek het laas jaar Junie by Fabrinox in die Paarl gewerk, dis 'n ent vanaf die Vrystaat, maar die ouens wat daar werk kan baie goed sweis. En ek weet in my tyd daar het die een ou baie met aliminium gewerk so hulle is baie goed. So ek dink dit kan geen skade maak om te bel en uit te vind of hulle vir jou kan help nie.

Thanks, waardeer
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Controversial I know - aluminium bike frames cannot be successfully welded once they break. That is because the frame is welded and then heat treated afterwards to make it harder, stiffer and stronger. If you weld it, the area around the weld lose its heat hardening and will then be weaker and break again. Many have tried and you can Google to find some prophets of aluminium repair, but I don't think they preach a mainstream gospel.

 

Best to replace i.m.h.o.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Controversial I know - aluminium bike frames cannot be successfully welded once they break. That is because the frame is welded and then heat treated afterwards to make it harder, stiffer and stronger. If you weld it, the area around the weld lose its heat hardening and will then be weaker and break again. Many have tried and you can Google to find some prophets of aluminium repair, but I don't think they preach a mainstream gospel.

 

Best to replace i.m.h.o.

Agreed, after consulting google. The big question is who is going to be able to assist me in locating this part in SA?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Try Danie at VIP Engineering, 17 Berg Street in Hilton, Bloemfontein. He did work on my car a few weeks back. He mentioned at the time that he had done work on bikes.They do aluminium welding.

 

Nothing to lose.

 

0825632257

0514306121

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vetseun daar is baie mense wat dit kan weld gaan dit hou? Die antwoord is nee. Kyk of jy nie iemand kan kry wat daai swingarm oorbou nie.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Try Danie at VIP Engineering, 17 Berg Street in Hilton, Bloemfontein. He did work on my car a few weeks back. He mentioned at the time that he had done work on bikes.They do aluminium welding.

 

Nothing to lose.

 

0825632257

0514306121

Thanks
Link to comment
Share on other sites

A GOOD welder can fix that and stronger than before.

 

Problem is finding that welder.

 

Alu frames are heat treated.

Will the frame not break in the same area again?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout