Jump to content

Canyon Stive vs. YT Capra vs. Radon Swoop 170


Odinson

  

28 members have voted

  1. 1. Your choice?

    • 2017 Canyon Strive AL 4.0 Race
      12
    • 2017 YT Capra AL
      7
    • 2017 Radon Swoop 170 7.0
      7
    • 2016 Radon Swoop 170 7.0
      2


Recommended Posts

Posted

At 175 I'd be wary of the large frame, if only due to the seat tube length limiting your choice of dropper due to your height - something this bike neeeeeds. You'll probably only be able to fit a 125mm dropper unless you have freakishly long legs for your height. If you're happy with that, well then that's okay.

 

From an ETT perspective the large is relatively short at 614 vs it's 473mm reach, and the medium is just under 600mm and with a reach of 460mm but - critically - with a 3cm shorter seat tube. 

 

On the face of it, I'd recommend a medium Swoop. It's still got a reach longer than that of my Large Reign. 

 

Yeah, was thinking about that too.

 

Opting for the medium will then push me over to either the 2016 Swoop (the 2X11 option with a Monarch instead of the Vivid Air) or the 2017 version with the Yari/Monarch. Alternatively, I have the option of the 2017 Swoop 170 8.0, which has the Lyrik/Vivid combo, but it'll be a €400 minimum jump in price, which ain't exactly chump change.  

  • Replies 42
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

At 175 I'd be wary of the large frame, if only due to the seat tube length limiting your choice of dropper due to your height - something this bike neeeeeds. You'll probably only be able to fit a 125mm dropper unless you have freakishly long legs for your height. If you're happy with that, well then that's okay. 

Great call. I didn't think about that at all when I bought my 150mm dropper only to find it didn't fit in my Dual Sus with the seat post kink. Luckily I just moved it over to my hardtail and it just fit's right other wise that would have been an expensive lesson. 

Posted

Well if a Spez was available as a direct sales model at comparable prices that would put one in the running - but they not and probably never will be.  

 

A longer bike makes a massive difference. My XL has 477 reach and it was a revelation moving from a short slack seat post bike to a 75deg seat tube and long reach/wheelbase frame.

Yes - true - but I found a brand new Enduro locally for about 50% of retail.... with warrantees intact - thanks to a hubber from the platteland.... :)

 

Guess Enduro is not so big in the flat lands... but it is worth looking around.

Posted

The Patrol is way out of budget, but seems to be a good bike.

Mr van aarde was selling his.... in XL.... if I remember right.... fabulous looking bike - but they don't make in my size... grr....

Posted

Mr van aarde was selling his.... in XL.... if I remember right.... fabulous looking bike - but they don't make in my size... grr....

 

They don't make an XXS?

Posted

But what would happen if I buy the Swoop and rock up to a race and okes are like "460mm reach and 170mm travel? You compensating for something?"

Posted

You obviously won't pass AS many okes on the climbs, but you'll be an absolute legend to ones you do.  :D

 

 

Now go my son! go and show an S-works that carbon is silly.

Posted

But what would happen if I buy the Swoop and rock up to a race and okes are like "460mm reach and 170mm travel? You compensating for something?"

The only person that is likely to know those numbers out their head is Myles.. and nobody takes him seriously...
Posted

Yes - true - but I found a brand new Enduro locally for about 50% of retail.... with warrantees intact - thanks to a hubber from the platteland.... :)

 

Guess Enduro is not so big in the flat lands... but it is worth looking around.

Yep, and my XL enduro was an old stock 26er frame for relatively little money. Would not be on one otherwise.

Posted

Cat among the pigeons here. What about some mid-travel naainers? They don't really qualify as long and slack, but y'know.

 

2017 Ghost SL AMR X 6 AL (150mm/140mm)

 

17am1144_slamr_x_6_al_u_29_titaniumgray_

 

2017 YT Jeffsy AL ONE

 

28.jpg

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout