Help a Buffalo!

[Wet Ears]

Here goes another one of those horrid please help me choose threads! I have a pretty good idea of what it is that I am looking for but thought it best to approach the Oracle aka the Hub readership for some advice.

 

Herewith the facts:

- Managed to secure a Sani2C entry so have started riding again - would like to upgrade bike as plan to do more races post Sani

- Price range is 60-70k

- I weigh 110kg and am just over 6 foot 

- Want a bike that ticks the above boxes 

 

I have done my homework and have narrowed my choices down to (in order of preference, I think):

i) Momsen Vipa 2

ii) Cannondale Scalpel Si

iii) Specialized Camber

iv) Cube AMS Pro 110

 

I was about to pull the trigger on the Momsen but then thought that with my weight would it not make sense going for a brand that offers a lifetime warranty on the frame a surely 110kgs in going to crack a carbon frame at some point?

 

Want to pull the trigger this week so any thoughts would be welcome!

 

Cheers 

[DIPSLICK]

I've ridden much heavier on a carbon frame

Santa Cruz is also in that range just saying,,,I haven't managed to break one yet,,,had a few

110 is the new 80

[pellieg]

if it was me id go for the Giant Anthem advanced  - life time warranty on the frame , super comfortable ride. good solid bike that you wont need a warranty for but its nice knowing its there, 

[Ferro]

Compare the first posts of the following two threads:

https://community.bikehub.co.za/topic/166919-warranty-issue-advice-required/

https://community.bikehub.co.za/topic/166758-thank-you-momsen/

[Tatt]

Some nice choices! As per usual, test them all, it will come down to the bike that puts the biggest smile on your face.

 

I would check the weights on the Specialized warranty - they used to sit between 95 and 105kgs if I remember correctly.

 

Tom

[Wet Ears]

Was considering a Santa Cruz but the Tallboy starts at 90k doesn't it?

I've ridden much heavier on a carbon frame
Santa Cruz is also in that range just saying,,,I haven't managed to break one yet,,,had a few
110 is the new 80

[Wet Ears]

Point taken - all good and well having a lifetime warranty until it is not honoured!

Compare the first posts of the following two threads:

https://community.bikehub.co.za/topic/166919-warranty-issue-advice-required/

https://community.bikehub.co.za/topic/166758-thank-you-momsen/

[Wet Ears]

Some nice choices! As per usual, test them all, it will come down to the bike that puts the biggest smile on your face.

 

I would check the weights on the Specialized warranty - they used to sit between 95 and 105kgs if I remember correctly.

 

Tom

Thanks - should hopefully be sub 105kg by end of Sani but will double check!!

[Wet Ears]

if it was me id go for the Giant Anthem advanced  - life time warranty on the frame , super comfortable ride. good solid bike that you wont need a warranty for but its nice knowing its there, 

Will go and have a squiz, thanks

[Wet Ears]

Some nice choices! As per usual, test them all, it will come down to the bike that puts the biggest smile on your face.

 

I would check the weights on the Specialized warranty - they used to sit between 95 and 105kgs if I remember correctly.

 

Tom

Sorry to sound like an ignoramus but don't the shops just let you take the bike for a spin in the car park?

[Ferro]

Either way you have a lekker shopping trip ahead of you. Much envy!

[ZakAttak]

How about the Pyga Stage? Or Stage Max? Got good reviews, homegrown eye candy...

[Wet Ears]

How about the Pyga Stage? Or Stage Max? Got good reviews, homegrown eye candy...

Had a look at Pyga and only reason for not choosing it is the positioning of the rear shock. Granted I know nothing about bike geometry etc but I am convinced that having the rear shock up near the top tube makes for a stiffer ride - which I prefer. 

[Rocket-Boy]

Im not trying to be funny but at your weight you arent going to be winning races, so a more comfortable bike with around 120mm travel would probably be the best.

 

I would say stay away from the twitchy race steeds and go for something with slightly more relaxed geo, the 'dale si, camber and stage max would be good for that.

[ZakAttak]

Had a look at Pyga and only reason for not choosing it is the positioning of the rear shock. Granted I know nothing about bike geometry etc but I am convinced that having the rear shock up near the top tube makes for a stiffer ride - which I prefer.

Maybe this will change your mind about your assumption:

 

https://www.bikehub.co.za/features/_/gear/reviews/review-pyga-stage-max-r5689?source=topic

 

Get something that will be comfortable during the long days in the saddle...

[Tatt]

Most bike shops will let you take a bike for a few days (well at least mine did here in Cape Town).

 

Don't discount the Pyga - they are extremely capable, and nothing beats a full floating suspension... Anyway, you may find this out on the Sani if you new wheels break down.

 

Tom