JensvD Posted August 23, 2019 Share I’ve been really happy riding a Camber Carbon Comp (large) for the last 5 years but it’s now coming to that stage where I’m going to have to start spending money on it (like getting a new fork…). I’m seriously considering getting a Stumpy ST instead but am unable get hold of a demo bike to try it out. Any comments from those in the know on how theses 2 bikes compare ridewise? I’ve also been advised that maybe an XL frame size may be more appropriate for me. I’m 188cm and 90kg. I guess it may be worth keeping an open mind about something like a Pyga Stage Max or Trek Fuel EX too... Any comments most appreciated… Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Robbie Stewart Posted August 23, 2019 Share I’ve been really happy riding a Camber Carbon Comp (large) for the last 5 years but it’s now coming to that stage where I’m going to have to start spending money on it (like getting a new fork…). I’m seriously considering getting a Stumpy ST instead but am unable get hold of a demo bike to try it out. Any comments from those in the know on how theses 2 bikes compare ridewise? I’ve also been advised that maybe an XL frame size may be more appropriate for me. I’m 188cm and 90kg. I guess it may be worth keeping an open mind about something like a Pyga Stage Max or Trek Fuel EX too... Any comments most appreciated… just...how? I am 1.90, 120..... As for the Camber's fork. I have a Camber with the RS Revelation. Do they die that quick? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jako De Wet Posted August 23, 2019 Share Hi there, I am 1.89, 84kgs and ride a 2019 XL Stumpy ST.I love the bike, but depending on which model you are planning to get, consider upgrading the brakes and get a 150mm dropper.I’ve been really happy riding a Camber Carbon Comp (large) for the last 5 years but it’s now coming to that stage where I’m going to have to start spending money on it (like getting a new fork…). I’m seriously considering getting a Stumpy ST instead but am unable get hold of a demo bike to try it out. Any comments from those in the know on how theses 2 bikes compare ridewise? I’ve also been advised that maybe an XL frame size may be more appropriate for me. I’m 188cm and 90kg. I guess it may be worth keeping an open mind about something like a Pyga Stage Max or Trek Fuel EX too...Any comments most appreciated… Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Markellis Posted August 23, 2019 Share I went from a s-works camber to a Pyga Stage. I loved my Camber and still think they one of the best bikes for SA type riding but... Do yourself a favour, ride the Pyga before making any decisions. I am completely blown away at how well the bike rides and climbs and I'm a 100km rider Edited August 23, 2019 by Markellis BigDL and nonky 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rudi Pollard Posted August 23, 2019 Share I’ve been really happy riding a Camber Carbon Comp (large) for the last 5 years but it’s now coming to that stage where I’m going to have to start spending money on it (like getting a new fork…). I’m seriously considering getting a Stumpy ST instead but am unable get hold of a demo bike to try it out. Any comments from those in the know on how theses 2 bikes compare ridewise? I’ve also been advised that maybe an XL frame size may be more appropriate for me. I’m 188cm and 90kg. I guess it may be worth keeping an open mind about something like a Pyga Stage Max or Trek Fuel EX too... Any comments most appreciated… You might have to wait a while before you'll be able to get a demo as I think they are currently selling the test fleet and awaiting the 2020 test bikes. Maybe phone around a bit to find out when they'll be available. I haven't ridden the new stumpy but looking at the geometry compared to the 2014 camber I assuming you have it is not comparable. The stumpy ST replaced the camber but I dont think it rides like a camber... Edited August 23, 2019 by RudolphP Eugéne Alberts 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TarThrasher Posted August 23, 2019 Share I’ve been really happy riding a Camber Carbon Comp (large) for the last 5 years but it’s now coming to that stage where I’m going to have to start spending money on it (like getting a new fork…). I’m seriously considering getting a Stumpy ST instead but am unable get hold of a demo bike to try it out. Any comments from those in the know on how theses 2 bikes compare ridewise? I’ve also been advised that maybe an XL frame size may be more appropriate for me. I’m 188cm and 90kg. I guess it may be worth keeping an open mind about something like a Pyga Stage Max or Trek Fuel EX too... Any comments most appreciated… I am +/- 1.82m and ride a large Fuel Ex. I really can't complain about it. It is extremely stable and planted, but can also climb relatively well. You would probably want to go for a XL on it though. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Eugéne Alberts Posted August 23, 2019 Share I think those are horses for different courses. Don't know what a correct replacement is for a camber but it's not a Stumpy. There is a huge difference in climbing ability whereas a fork upgrade on the camber goes a long way to bridge the gap in downhill performance. Edited August 23, 2019 by Eugéne Alberts Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bullet77 Posted August 23, 2019 Share I think those are horses for different courses. Don't know what a correct replacement is for a camber but it's not a Stumpy. There is a huge difference in climbing ability whereas a fork upgrade on the camber goes a long way to bridge the gap in downhill performance.Stumpy ST(short travel)=Camber Edited August 23, 2019 by bullet77 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hairy Posted August 23, 2019 Share Been running similar ideas through my head ... this is a geo chart I have put together showing the comparison. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
nonky Posted August 23, 2019 Share I went from a s-works camber to a Pyga Stage. I loved my Camber and still think they one of the best bikes for SA type riding but... Do yourself a favour, ride the Pyga before making any decisions. I am completely blown away at how well the bike rides and climbs and I'm a 100km rider i have heard this ^^^^^ from more than one Stage owner. BigDL 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
nonky Posted August 23, 2019 Share just...how? I am 1.90, 120..... As for the Camber's fork. I have a Camber with the RS Revelation. Do they die that quick?No, but they do like a service now and then. Also, mine had the damper replaced fairly early (1 yr) Robbie Stewart 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
nonky Posted August 23, 2019 Share I’ve been really happy riding a Camber Carbon Comp (large) for the last 5 years but it’s now coming to that stage where I’m going to have to start spending money on it (like getting a new fork…). I’m seriously considering getting a Stumpy ST instead but am unable get hold of a demo bike to try it out. Any comments from those in the know on how theses 2 bikes compare ridewise? I’ve also been advised that maybe an XL frame size may be more appropriate for me. I’m 188cm and 90kg. I guess it may be worth keeping an open mind about something like a Pyga Stage Max or Trek Fuel EX too... Any comments most appreciated… If you want a very similar bike to your Camber, then the Epic Evo has almost exactly the same geometry as the last Camber model. Your views on the brain shock will probably help make up your mind. With the newer bikes (modern geo), I don't think the sizing makes such a large difference and you could easily move up to an XL on the Epic. The New Stumpy is much more of a TRAIL bike than the Camber, which is more XC orientated. Be clear about what you're gonna use the bike for. Happy hunting! Hairy 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kuys Posted August 23, 2019 Share If you want a very similar bike to your Camber, then the Epic Evo has almost exactly the same geometry as the last Camber model. Your views on the brain shock will probably help make up your mind. With the newer bikes (modern geo), I don't think the sizing makes such a large difference and you could easily move up to an XL on the Epic. The New Stumpy is much more of a TRAIL bike than the Camber, which is more XC orientated. Be clear about what you're gonna use the bike for. Happy hunting!Dont confuse the Stumpy with the Stumpy ST. As stated earlier in the thread, the new Stumpy ST = Camber. Only real difference between them is the slightly slacker head tube angle and longer reach of the new Stumpy ST Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
River Rat Posted August 23, 2019 Share Dont confuse the Stumpy with the Stumpy ST. As stated earlier in the thread, the new Stumpy ST = Camber. Only real difference between them is the slightly slacker head tube angle and longer reach of the new Stumpy STI beg to differ I ride the Stumpy ST and it is fundamentally different to the Camber just on travel alone 130 vs 120. My wife has the Epic Evo and that rides like a Camber at 120mm travel. Bear in mind that the Stumpy St travel can be upgraded to 140mm if needed which puts it closer to the enduro level. nonky and Hairy 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JensvD Posted August 23, 2019 Share just...how? I am 1.90, 120..... As for the Camber's fork. I have a Camber with the RS Revelation. Do they die that quick? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JensvD Posted August 23, 2019 Share just...how? I am 1.90, 120..... As for the Camber's fork. I have a Camber with the RS Revelation. Do they die that quick?Fox Evolution. Not quite dead yet but some wear on the stanchions requiring more frequent replacement of seals. Robbie Stewart 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now