Jump to content

Which is the best Mudguard ?  

15 members have voted

  1. 1. Which is the best Mudguard ?

    • Topeak FX
      164
    • THE Pro XC
      267


Recommended Posts

Posted

Here's a  possible solution to the "weak" mounting bracket (and here comes my winning pair of Shimano shoes) on the Topeak or for the matter any mudguard.

 

Mount a spare star nut to the underside of the steerer tube and use that as a mounting point (albeit semi-permanently).

 

I'll take the road shoes thank you very much Wink

 

 

  • Replies 38
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
mandibles' date=' i think they look good on some bikes. but generally i agree, theu can look quite uncool. i have attached one like this - not the exact one, myine cost R35 - to my singlespeed. they're more subtle and hidden away under the down tube
[/quote']

 

I agree HR. Thug has a similar one on his bike. It is acceptable by my standards however even a carrier brace looks more cool on my baby than mudguards. Wink I don't like plastic on my bike.
Posted

 

 

This Hubber says that The Thug is stirring. The discussion wasn't about coolness. My opinion is that no mudguards are cool.

 

 

err.......... hello Mandibles

 

The issue (or should that be THE issue) was not whether it looks cool on your bike or not !

 

LOL

 

Posted

 

Have had a rather animated discussion over the past couple of days with a couple of Hubbers as to which is the "coolest" front mudguard.

 

Here are the contenders:

 

In terms of price....

 

Topeak - R 140

THE - R 260

 

So what say the Hubbers ?

 

 

This Hubber says that The Thug is stirring. The discussion wasn't about coolness. My opinion is that no mudguards are cool.

 

Topeak cost me R95 and THE was quoted as costing R280. Topeak is the best value-for-money seeing as the mudguard will only be allowed on my mtb when it is absolutely necessary.

 

Why want something that breaks when you need it???

 

Posted
Have had a rather animated discussion over the past couple of days with a couple of Hubbers as to which is the "coolest" front mudguard.


err.......... hello Mandibles

The issue (or should that be THE issue) was not whether it looks cool on your bike or not !

LOL

 

Confused
Posted

I had a Mudgaurd once, after it fell off I just left it in the road, the thing kept on rattling loose. Do what one of the Warthogs do, use a water bottle, cut it a bit and stick it under your seat, bam, problem solved, going to cost you R4.99

Posted

mandibles' date=' i think they look good on some bikes. but generally i agree, theu can look quite uncool. i have attached one like this - not the exact one, myine cost R35 - to my singlespeed. they're more subtle and hidden away under the down tube [/quote']

 

?

 

I agree HR. Thug has a similar one on his bike.?It is acceptable by my standards however even?a carrier brace looks more cool on my baby than mudguards. https://www.bikehub.co.za/smileys/smiley2.gif" height="17" width="17" align="absmiddle" alt="Wink" />?I don't like plastic on my bike.

 

 

 

smiley36.gif smiley36.gif smiley36.gif

 

 

 

then you won't like stg!'s plastic bottle mudguard. yip, the one that won the bicycling tip prize this week

Posted

HR, also got one of those now permanently on my bike(it is after all, only a Schwinn MesaWink). It works quite well, also protects your downtube from rocks thrown up by the front wheel.

Bought mine at Game, about R30.00
Posted
Mount a spare star nut to the underside of the steerer tube and use that as a mounting point

 

Exactly what I did when I got my topeak. An easy solution to over paying for the THE, R280 - R300 for a piece of injection moulded plastic, come of it. LOL

 

What do those BBB ones go for I wonder?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout