Jump to content

MTB Tire Direction


Ysterman

Recommended Posts

oh' date=' and what about the bunny park?
[/quote']

 

Bunny numbers seem to have recovered since last we spoke on this.

 

 

They're from Bun-oni.

 

Sorry

 

 

Sort of

 

 
Joe Low2008-10-02 05:40:54
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 161
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

oh' date=' and what about the bunny park?
[/quote']

 

Bunny numbers seem to have recovered since last we spoke on this.

 

 

They're from Bun-oni.

 

Sorry

 

 

Sort of

 

 

 

you know what they say about bunnies?Wink
Link to comment
Share on other sites


and the slippy slide at Waterworld in Benoni.

 

 

 

 

Correction Johan' date=' it's called Wild Waters and its situated in Boksburg.
[/quote']

 

and a rave held there gave us vernon koekemoer.

 

Wild waters LOL still going strong, does the wave pool still work??

 

Going back to the tyre (or is it tires) direction thread.... BEST advice is to install it as per the manufactures recomendation arrows or whatever...

 

Remember doing a race once (Karkloof classic) and while standing on the start line pointed out to one of my subvet racing mates/competitors that his front tyre was installed the wrong way (tyre direction arrow was pointing backwards)... Needless to say he had a terrible race and complained that he felt like he was loosing the front end on corners...

 

Never under estimate the power of the mind hehe!!!

 

 

 

 

 

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites


and the slippy slide at Waterworld in Benoni.

 

 

 

 

Correction Johan' date=' it's called Wild Waters and its situated in Boksburg.
[/quote']

 

and a rave held there gave us vernon koekemoer.

 

Wild waters LOL still going strong, does the wave pool still work??

 

yup, still going strong. actually, the old man of a schoolmate of mine built that place.
Link to comment
Share on other sites


and the slippy slide at Waterworld in Benoni.

 

 

 

 

Correction Johan' date=' it's called Wild Waters and its situated in Boksburg.
[/quote']

 

and a rave held there gave us vernon koekemoer.

 

Wild waters LOL still going strong, does the wave pool still work??

 

Going back to the tyre (or is it tires) direction thread.... BEST advice is to install it as per the manufactures recomendation arrows or whatever...

 

Remember doing a race once (Karkloof classic) and while standing on the start line pointed out to one of my subvet racing mates/competitors that his front tyre was installed the wrong way (tyre direction arrow was pointing backwards)... Needless to say he had a terrible race and complained that he felt like he was loosing the front end on corners...

 

Never under estimate the power of the mind hehe!!!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

talk about a reverse in performance.LOL
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Well' date=' it clearly has nothing to do with tread patterns, cause I've ridden that hill many times and the rear wheel slips, if standing OR sitting, on the road bike...

[/quote']

 

Look TNT, you have enough experience with mature debate to know that it is easy to find extreme examples to disprove just about anything. I did say ice-rinks excluded. Why force me to exclude a bed of ball bearings, a slimy shiny wet tar road, a conveyor belt in a vaseline factory and the slippy slide at Waterworld in Benoni.

 

There are plenty of situations where traction is extremely limited. Point remains, turning your tyre around under those (or any other) conditions will not suddenly return traction.

 

 

 

But, conveyor belt in a vaseline factory, was classic, we wouldn't have got it otherwiseBig%20smile

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Well' date=' it clearly has nothing to do with tread patterns, cause I've ridden that hill many times and the rear wheel slips, if standing OR sitting, on the road bike...
[/quote']

 

Look TNT, you have enough experience with mature debate to know that it is easy to find extreme examples to disprove just about anything. I did say ice-rinks excluded. Why force me to exclude a bed of ball bearings, a slimy shiny wet tar road, a conveyor belt in a vaseline factory and the slippy slide at Waterworld in Benoni.

 

There are plenty of situations where traction is extremely limited. Point remains, turning your tyre around under those (or any other) conditions will not suddenly return traction.

 

 


But, conveyor belt in a vaseline factory, was classic, we wouldn't have got it otherwiseBig%20smile

 

 

so KY jelly is still okay?  Cleans disc brakes like a charm.Wink
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Well' date=' it clearly has nothing to do with tread patterns, cause I've ridden that hill many times and the rear wheel slips, if standing OR sitting, on the road bike...

[/quote']

 

Look TNT, you have enough experience with mature debate to know that it is easy to find extreme examples to disprove just about anything. I did say ice-rinks excluded. Why force me to exclude a bed of ball bearings, a slimy shiny wet tar road, a conveyor belt in a vaseline factory and the slippy slide at Waterworld in Benoni.

 

There are plenty of situations where traction is extremely limited. Point remains, turning your tyre around under those (or any other) conditions will not suddenly return traction.

 

 

 

But, conveyor belt in a vaseline factory, was classic, we wouldn't have got it otherwiseBig%20smile

 

 

so KY jelly is still okay?  Cleans disc brakes like a charm.Wink

 

Just don't put it on the tyre tread, don't want accidental backdoor action...ConfusedConfused

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some excellent posts by JB and Golefty - sound technical arguments. Well done guys Clap sounds like you know what you are talking about.

 

Very little of substance was said to argue against their position, except that we should belive the marketing of the big tyre companies because they always tell the truth? Very poor show, just from reading this it seems like the hubbers in opposition are pretty clueless, but keeps on arguing.

 

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

Ok, so tell me something then - and let's exclude ramped leading edges of blocks from this discussion...

 

 

 

For tread patterns that have some form of v shape, I always figured the v should point in the direction of force - for power (can't thing of a better description) at the rear and for braking at the front. Reason being that if you are on loose material, the tyre will slip and (hopefully) scoot the loose material away, allowing traction on harder surface below the loose stuff.

 

 

 

The opposite would happen if they were reversed - loose stuff would get pulled under the tyre and provide poorer traction.

 

 

 

Anyone care to tell me why I am wrong?

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Now that the Hamas and Israel have calmed down, out pops Dave with this tried and proven missile. Wink

 

OK, I'll try though. Your question has several elements in but I'm going to deal with the one about the V-shape moving material in and out of the tyre.

 

Most of these V-shapes in tyres are inspired not by real function but by the average tyre owner's perception of how things should work. Most of them in turn are inspired by the distinctive V-shape of a tractor's rear tyre. Their argument is that if this is good enoug for a tractor, it should be good enough for my BMW/Motorbike/Bicycle.

 

Truth is, the V-shape works very well on a tractor and its function is purely to expel mud from the tyre and attempt to have the tyre make contact with harder substrate. On a tractor tyre it works. The tyre bed is smooth and the Vs have nice smooth shoulders where they meet the tyre. The tyre's shape is tubular.

 

Mud is squeezed out quite nicely and it is interesting to watch those Vs at work.

 

However, the process doesn't scale down well. On a macro scale the mud move, on a micro scale not. I consider car/4X4 and MTB tyres a micro scale.

 

Here it doesn't work. Although a motorbike or bicycle tyre is also tubular, the crud is coarser than what those little channels can handle. As you say, you want even gravel to be maneuvred by those tyres. That doesn't happen in real life.

 

Likelise, siping grooves in bicycle tyres don't work. On a car tyre where the surface area is large and the contact patch is square, water is moved out by grooves, but not on a bicycle tyre. Here the boat shape of the tyre does all the water evacuation.

 

 

 

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

correct, the shape of the grooves on bicycle tyres means nothing. The fancy patterns merely appeal to your subconscious.

 

Generally on bicycle tyres,

v-shapes just give the perception of more grip so you are more committed in corners, thus riding faster. You think it's the tyre but it's actually the rubber and the size of your balls.

 

on mtb tyres the only mud clearing factors are, rubber compound, space between tread blocks and roundness of the edges between tread blocks.

 

Edges that face each other do not clear well, edges that rest at angles to each other do.

Thats why Conti Mountain King tyre works so well in all conditions. No two edges are parallel.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

correct' date=' the shape of the grooves on bicycle tyres means nothing. The fancy patterns merely appeal to your subconscious.

 

Generally on bicycle tyres,

v-shapes just give the perception of more grip so you are more committed in corners, thus riding faster. You think it's the tyre but it's actually the rubber and the size of your balls.

 

on mtb tyres the only mud clearing factors are, rubber compound, space between tread blocks and roundness of the edges between tread blocks.

 

Edges that face each other do not clear well, edges that rest at angles to each other do.

Thats why Conti Mountain King tyre works so well in all conditions. No two edges are parallel.
[/quote']

 

Welcome back. Where have you been?

 

There's an interesting Scandium discussionin the KMCNC thread. Go play.

 

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats why Conti Mountain King tyre works so well in all conditions. No two edges are parallel.

Strange you should mention that - I'm not happy with my MK's at all.  Front nearly slid out from under me on one of the downhills at Barberton - in a place it really shouldn't have.  Mate of mine in the UK also doesn't rate them... Also when I ride on a slope, it feels like the rear wheel is tracking downhill of the front wheel.  And for anyone who's going to tell me that this is how it should be, this is more so than for any other tyre I've used.  As hard as I try to like them, I'm failing miserably.

 

Which leads one to think that maybe there is more to the shape of the grooves than is given credence.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout