Coaches-cum-selectors?

[SwissVan]

Thanks to The Doctor for the very clear and comprehensive response.

 

Given that the OP's post was directed at Dr. Swart specifically, and that he has responded to the questions raised, it will be closed shortly.

 

Maybe wait until Friday 5pm to give the OP time to try explain his point of view better?

 

So far his silence is not doing himself any favors

 

Edited September 19, 2013 by SwissVan

[Santa C]

 

 

Not enough and not often enough.

 

Agree...the more often the better! In all sport

[Andyr249]

Maybe wait until Friday 5pm to give the OP time to try explain his point of view better?

 

So far his silence is not doing himself any favors

 

 

Exactly.

 

But also if he had spent a "fair number of years observing the local racing" scene then he should have heard who the Doctor was.

[GLuvsMtb]

Thanks Doc for clearing this up. EVERY selector in every sport has a vested interest somewhere. So does referees and umpires Does that mean that Jonker, Kaplan and Lawrence are never to referee, be assistant referee or TMO in a game where the Springboks play?

[V12man]

Don't hold your breath...

 

I won't.... but then I am not that dumb....

[SwissVan]

 

 

Exactly.

 

But also if he had spent a "fair number of years observing the local racing" scene then he should have heard who the Doctor was.

 

That's no guarantee..... sure you know the tall tree and wind story or maybe the bigger you are the harder the fall story

 

Just check out the recent prime minister if Italy

 

 

 

[ccc2]

I understand that the general cred of CSA is pretty low on thehubsa but then the cred of thehubsa is pretty low with CSA

just couldn't resist - good bye , i'm gone

Edited September 19, 2013 by ccc2

[JGR]

Thanks Doc for clearing this up. EVERY selector in every sport has a vested interest somewhere. So does referees and umpires Does that mean that Jonker, Kaplan and Lawrence are never to referee, be assistant referee or TMO in a game where the Springboks play?

Thats correct - thats also the reason why we get this crap french guy in the championship . Australia only have Steve Walsh (who is on the IRB panel) and he is a NZ'er so is also not considered for games between the boks and all blacks

 

This does not apply to S15 thought

['Dale]

just couldn't resist - good bye , i'm gone

 

Heehee

[Andyr249]

Still no response from the OP?

[DIPSLICK]

Still no response from the OP?

Because the OP at no stage was here for an answer ,,op was here to stir, and slate.....and got his ass handed to him by facts

Edited September 22, 2013 by dipslick

['Dale]

 

Because the OP at no stage was here for an answer ,,op was here to stir, and slate.....and got his ass handed to him by facts

 

Yip, seemingly intending to discrediting a medical PRO.

 

:-/

Edited September 22, 2013 by ' Dale