Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

At the end of the day, it's all quite difficult to police... and there are a lot of grey areas.

 

If it were cut and dry then the following should probably also wear helmets at all times "in the event of an acident":

  • people riding in boats or participating in water sports
  • skateboarders and roller bladers (yes, some do... and only in skate parks, but most don't)
  • rugby players & other contact sports (not specifically "helmets", but scrum caps)
  • skiers & snowboarders (again, some do, but many don't).
  • speed walkers
  • break dancers
  • people commuting by bus (or any other mode of stransport without seat belts)
  • figure skaters (or any other recreational ice skating)
  • fruit pickers

The list could go on. Point being, that there are infinite amounts of activities wher head injuries could be sustained. If one were to set difinitive rule, then all these would be open to criticism.

 

I'm also not advocating the non-use of helmets. I wear mine prety much all the time. But there are occaions where I quickly test out that new part in the driveway or ride around the parkinglot waiting for my friends to arrive. I probably should wear a helmet, even for these. But to many the nature of the exercise seems harmless enough... just like to others pedalling their bike in flip-flops round the park with their kids seems equally as harmless.

 

I personally can't restain myself from trying something stupid, so it's better if I always wear mine, haha

Edited by patches
  • Replies 176
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

we want details

 

cyclists leaves car park at 8;15

travels at a speed of approx 6,8km/h average

the wind is from the front(as it always is)

 

details details

 

And a train leaves the top of the trail at 8::35 traveling at approximately 22km/h avg.

 

What is the name of the passenger in seat 4G.

Posted

Serious question. Since breaking necks etc is all a casual injury.

 

learn to read, I said riding casually, not falling casually.

Posted

TONSIL

 

It is not worth arguing or discussing anymore, this thread has turned into people who promote riding with helmets and the rest who just want to argue for the sake of it.

Posted

It does. An adult without a helmet riding casually in lets say Emmarentia, a dog comes running without a leash, as they usually do, hits the adult, adult goes down, hits head against the tar, breaks neck and a concussion.

 

An adult drive his car casually in a quiet suburb, with a kid not buckled down in the back/front seat...a dog runs in front of the car, adult brakes, kid hits dashboard, breaks neck.

 

Please tell me how this analogy is so pointless as you say?

Accidents happen when you least expect them, because, you don't expect them, that's the whole argument.

In a race, a downhill, a slow ride in a park, accidents happen.

 

Not to stir the pot or anything but if you riding casually in Emmerentia and a dog comes running you can stop, you generally die if you break your neck :blink:

 

If you going for a Strava KOM on the treeline and said pooch runs in front of you, you deserve whatever comes your way... lid or no lid

Posted

At the end of the day, it's all quite difficult to police... and there are a lot of grey areas.

 

If it were cut and dry then the following should probably also wear helmets at all times "in the event of an acident":

  • people riding in boats or participating in water sports
  • skateboarders and roller bladers (yes, some do... and only in skate parks, but most don't)
  • rugby players & other contact sports (not specifically "helmets", but scrum caps)
  • skiers & snowboarders (again, some do, but many don't).
  • speed walkers
  • break dancers
  • people commuting by bus (or any other mode of stransport without seat belts)
  • figure skaters (or any other recreational ice skating)
  • fruit pickers

The list could go on. Point being, that there are infinite amounts of activities wher head injuries could be sustained. If one were to set difinitive rule, then all these would be open to criticism.

 

I'm also not advocating the non-use of helmets. I wear mine prety much all the time. But there are occaions where I quickly test out that new part in the driveway or ride around the parkinglot waiting for my friends to arrive. I probably should wear a helmet, even for these. But to many the nature of the exercise seems harmless enough... just like to others pedalling their bike in flip-flops round the park with their kids seems equally as harmless.

 

I personally can't restain myself from trying something stupid, so it's better if I always wear mine, haha

A friend has gone down in a skateboard fall about 3 weeks ago now, he was critical, in coma, still has not got movement on the RHS of his body.

 

Doc recons that anything over 18km/h requires a helmet.

 

Don't %$^# around boys and girls, wear the damned thing as it is not only you that is effected by taking a serious tumble, but also those around you.

Posted

Not to stir the pot or anything but if you riding casually in Emmerentia and a dog comes running you can stop, you generally die if you break your neck :blink:

 

If you going for a Strava KOM on the treeline and said pooch runs in front of you, you deserve whatever comes your way... lid or no lid

 

You stir the pot? Don't be ridiculous

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout