Jump to content

Are carbon road wheels worth it?


andreas17777

Recommended Posts

Posted

My zipp 404 FCs are about 2kmh faster average speed than my Shamals on any given day for the same fitness and route. My Zondas are 1kmh faster than the shamals though. They are 17c vs 15c. All sets have 25c Conti GP4000s

 

Zondas are 5k ... Shamals 13k  Zipps 28k

 

No money - buy the Zondas with credit card .

Got cash to bling - buy the Zipps

Got just enough - get Shamal 17c 

  • Replies 49
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

My zipp 404 FCs are about 2kmh faster average speed than my Shamals on any given day for the same fitness and route. My Zondas are 1kmh faster than the shamals though. They are 17c vs 15c. All sets have 25c Conti GP4000s

 

Zondas are 5k ... Shamals 13k Zipps 28k

 

No money - buy the Zondas with credit card .

Got cash to bling - buy the Zipps

Got just enough - get Shamal 17c

I currently have Zonda’s, thanks fir the input.

Posted

Morning y’all, so which rims are actually worth getting? Where do I go to shop for rims? And NO, deep pockets I dnt have (just bought a bike) I am currently running on Campy Scirocco 35mm

Posted

My zipp 404 FCs are about 2kmh faster average speed than my Shamals on any given day for the same fitness and route. My Zondas are 1kmh faster than the shamals though. They are 17c vs 15c. All sets have 25c Conti GP4000s

 

Zondas are 5k ... Shamals 13k  Zipps 28k

 

No money - buy the Zondas with credit card .

Got cash to bling - buy the Zipps

Got just enough - get Shamal 17c 

 

You left out the Eurus.

Oh those Shamals roll so, so nicely though.

 

I'm also a Campy wheel fan, those wheels are awesome

Posted

Carbon rims are great for eating up some of that road buzz. 

My average speeds are faster on carbon than aluminium. 

So are you saying carbon rims are like a carbon frame  and can actually reduce road buzz if made correctly. I was always under the impression that carbon rims were more rigid than ally, so were harsher than ally rims, or am i misinformed?

Posted

I rode with Chinese carbons for three years training. They were good value for money. The front wheel melted in a race coming down a mountain pass. So don't use them on very hilly races. I believe this is possible with most carbon wheels that are clinchers.

 

I had Campag Boras that were 10 years old, they were very fast on flats. Gave them to my son, now he races with them. Before that I had old Zipps 404's they climbed very well because the back wheel is so stiff. Also pretty fast on the flats. Maybe as fast as the Boras'. These were both tubbies, which are better imo for races, they can ride through potholes and the clinchers can't really. The tubbies are less likely to delaminate from braking heat because the braking surface is not being pushed apart by the tire, the tire at 10 bar actually strengthens the wheel, punctures are a pain through, as it is not so easy to repair the tubbies.

Posted

My zipp 404 FCs are about 2kmh faster average speed than my Shamals on any given day for the same fitness and route. My Zondas are 1kmh faster than the shamals though. They are 17c vs 15c. All sets have 25c Conti GP4000s

 

Zondas are 5k ... Shamals 13k  Zipps 28k

 

No money - buy the Zondas with credit card .

Got cash to bling - buy the Zipps

Got just enough - get Shamal 17c 

If the Zondas are quicker than the Shamals, why even consider the Shamals?

Posted

So are you saying carbon rims are like a carbon frame  and can actually reduce road buzz if made correctly. I was always under the impression that carbon rims were more rigid than ally, so were harsher than ally rims, or am i misinformed?

On carbon rims, I have noticed less feedback from the road when cycling over uneven surfaces.  

Posted

If the Zondas are quicker than the Shamals, why even consider the Shamals?

I think he said get the 17 Shamals, as opposed the the 15 which he had. :)

Posted

Quick question, everyone says that carbon wheels can melt/delaminate when doing too much decending or breaking on steep decents but I've noticed all those videos and articles ect are from Europe.

 

Here in Cape Town however, our climbs are nothing compared to the climbs in the other parts of the world so my question is should one be concerned about the possibilty of melting/delamination due to braking on what we would consider steep/long decents here by us?

Posted

High speeds - Carbon 50mm

Very high speeds - Carbon 60-80mm

Climbing - alu OR carbon 35mm

 

So, it depends on your location where you ride/train, and the types of races you partake in. 

 

My personal experience - they accelerate better, but the weight advantage isn't as much as one hopes. Braking the wet is ***. Noise from the brake pads suck. Proper pads are expensive. But they sound wonderful (rolling).

Posted

So are you saying carbon rims are like a carbon frame  and can actually reduce road buzz if made correctly. I was always under the impression that carbon rims were more rigid than ally, so were harsher than ally rims, or am i misinformed?

Carbon is designed to be stiffer, which gives the impression that power transfer in more efficient (less loss through flex). Aluminium is a more compliant material, but there is the slightest weight penalty. Bike manufacturers are hard at work making carbon frames more comfortable. Aero bikes for example have a generally stiffer chassis compared to the comfort ranges, so NOT recommended for races like the Fast one  :whistling:  :whistling:  :whistling:

Posted

Quick question, everyone says that carbon wheels can melt/delaminate when doing too much decending or breaking on steep decents but I've noticed all those videos and articles ect are from Europe.

 

Here in Cape Town however, our climbs are nothing compared to the climbs in the other parts of the world so my question is should one be concerned about the possibilty of melting/delamination due to braking on what we would consider steep/long decents here by us?

 

https://www.bikeradar.com/road/gear/article/alto-destroys-carbon-clinchers-in-braking-heat-test-51474/

 

In a word yes, top brands of rims destroyed in 300 seconds of braking. This is for clinchers, I believe tubbies would perform better as there is no outward pressure if the rim is slightly plasticised.

 

My rim melted coming down De Beers pass near Ladysmith, it was pretty steep, the rim melted about one third the way down the pass. I was braking a lot.

Posted

Quick question, everyone says that carbon wheels can melt/delaminate when doing too much decending or breaking on steep decents but I've noticed all those videos and articles ect are from Europe.

 

Here in Cape Town however, our climbs are nothing compared to the climbs in the other parts of the world so my question is should one be concerned about the possibilty of melting/delamination due to braking on what we would consider steep/long decents here by us?

 

 

Agree with what Martin has said.

From the research that I've done the problem is with carbon clincher deep sections. Tubbies don't seem to have the braking problem or it's a lot less significant.

 

In SA they still melt. Know somebody who used a Chinese carbon set for about 3 or 4 years and then the brake pad went through as it had worn out.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout