What justifies replacing a helmet?

[Scott roy]

So I know you’re meant to replace your helmet if it gets any impact of any sorts but just how true is this? 
 

This afternoon I crashed with a brand new helmet and the helmet received some fair impact however there’s not really a dent or anything, just a bit of a scrape mark. Should I really replace it?  It feels wrong to since it’s a new helmet

I read that even dropping your helmet compromises it ,is it really that bad?

 

thanks in advance

[Me rida my bicycle]

I would look for cracks on the inside. No dents or cracks should be fine. 

This is just my opinion. 

[Thomo]

  On 3/21/2023 at 8:29 PM, Me rida my bicycle said:

I would look for cracks on the inside.

Expand  

Definitely do this.

I remember my helmet looking perfectly fine on the outside after a crash, but looking inside revealed multiple cracks.

[Graham W]

Some brands come with a crash replacement warranty  worth checking with your LBS

[NC_lurker]

Check what the crash replacement policy is on the brand. You should get 40-60% off the price of a replacement unit.

Given that the helmet is there to protect a fairly valuable part of your anatomy rather don't risk it..

Also, try squeeze the helmet. Sometimes small cracks are difficult to see but if the helmet has any give, then they're there.

Edited March 21, 2023 by NC_lurker
More info

[sirmoun10goat]

Replace. The shell often doesn’t show any damage, but what you can’t see is the compression to the materials under the shell. Once this is compacted, there is no more impact absorption 

[Chadvdw67]

FWIW, when I was still riding dirtbikes, I had a big fall one time that landed me up in hospital for a week with a severe concussion, the helmet didnt even have a scratch on it after the fall........

[Scott roy]

  On 3/21/2023 at 9:06 PM, NC_lurker said:

Check what the crash replacement policy is on the brand. You should get 40-60% off the price of a replacement unit.

Given that the helmet is there to protect a fairly valuable part of your anatomy rather don't risk it..

Also, try squeeze the helmet. Sometimes small cracks are difficult to see but if the helmet has any give, then they're there.

Expand  

Thanks ,any idea if Scott do the cash replacement? It’s a Scott centric plus

[Scott roy]

  On 3/22/2023 at 12:27 AM, sirmoun10goat said:

Replace. The shell often doesn’t show any damage, but what you can’t see is the compression to the materials under the shell. Once this is compacted, there is no more impact absorption 

Expand  

Thanks ,makes sense

[SoloCyclist]

No question.......... REPLACE

Helmet done its job.......

This is why I refuse to buy 2nd hand helmets because you wont know the history

Edited March 22, 2023 by SoloCyclist

[NC_lurker]

  On 3/22/2023 at 4:44 AM, Scott roy said:

Thanks ,any idea if Scott do the cash replacement? It’s a Scott centric plus

Expand  

Sorry, only dealt with Bell, Giro & Lazer.

Contact the shop you bought it from, they'll sort it out with the distributor.

[Scott roy]

Just went to cyclelab ,they have contacted Scott and hopefully I’ll have a new helmet in the next 5 days 

[ChrisF]

  On 3/22/2023 at 8:46 AM, NC_lurker said:

Sorry, only dealt with Bell, Giro & Lazer.

Contact the shop you bought it from, they'll sort it out with the distributor.

Expand  

 

Does Lazer do replacement ?

 

Destroyed my Scott previous Saturday, and could only get a Lazer at 17:00 on a Saturday afternoon with a race on Sunday morning.  Certainly fits nicely.  New to the Lazer brand ....

[NC_lurker]

  On 3/22/2023 at 12:07 PM, ChrisF said:

 

Does Lazer do replacement ?

 

Destroyed my Scott previous Saturday, and could only get a Lazer at 17:00 on a Saturday afternoon with a race on Sunday morning.  Certainly fits nicely.  New to the Lazer brand ....

Expand  

Yup. 50% off a replacement. Ensuring that you buy a brand that offers a decent crash replacement policy makes it far easier to just always err on the side of caution when it comes to replacing the helmet.

I recently tested the policy, couldn't fault the service received. Just make sure to always keep an electronic copy of your sales invoice/slip when purchasing.

https://www.lazersport.com/global/crash-replacement-program

[NC_lurker]

  On 3/22/2023 at 8:58 AM, Scott roy said:

Just went to cyclelab ,they have contacted Scott and hopefully I’ll have a new helmet in the next 5 days 

Expand  

Out of interest, please let us know what discount you get on the replacement. Thanks 

[Bub Marley]

I recently had an Oakley replaced under crash replacement policy. They contributed 50% of the retail value at the time of purchase.

Just got myself a Giro now and according to salesman, they also come with a crash replacement policy.