Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 3.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Well you are making loads of assumptions as well. I never said it was professionally put together. I said it was deliberately put together. You ASSUME it is just a pick of guy chilling. You also appear to assume I am being negative about LA. I am not

 

My only interest is the way photography is being used in this instance and I assure you my excitement over it was concerned with how effective it is. The fact it is not professional adds to its charm. It's effectiveness is demonstrated by how widely and rapidly it was disseminated. It was even on SKY last night.

 

You could use this image for a fine art thesis

 

Also not picking a fight but please don't assume to understand my motivations or try to tell me that they are other than what I say.

Posted

Well you are making loads of assumptions as well. I never said it was professionally put together. I said it was deliberately put together. You ASSUME it is just a pick of guy chilling. You also appear to assume I am being negative about LA. I am not

 

My only interest is the way photography is being used in this instance and I assure you my excitement over it was concerned with how effective it is. The fact it is not professional adds to its charm. It's effectiveness is demonstrated by how widely and rapidly it was disseminated. It was even on SKY last night.

 

You could use this image for a fine art thesis

 

Also not picking a fight but please don't assume to understand my motivations or try to tell me that they are other than what I say.

 

 

 

As I said , I am not picking a fight, seems you are not happy with that, so let's fight.

 

Did I completely and utterly misunderstand this statement ?

 

"It requires a little bit of planning and a little bit of post production. It is not merely a snap shot that someone pops off."

 

 

I will say it again, for the third time.

The same effect can be achieved with an i-phone.

 

You also assumed, that I assumed you were being negative about Armstrong.

No.

I just find the little essays people are scribbling around him rather amusing.

Guy drops his hat, and we can do a two page essay as to what his motive was behind it, it's laughable.

Posted

I see Armstrong made a statement of sorts. He posted an image of himself on twitter relaxing at his home on a couch with 7 huge frames behind him on the wall, each one containing a yellow jersy from the TDF.

 

I guess that says it all from his point of view and from the point of view of his supporters

 

I'm not a LA fan - but this is classic!!

 

It's about as big a F@@@ YOU!!! to the world as the guy could give. And for someone is his position, why not?

Posted

The most surprising thing about that photo is that it's proof that the muppit from USADA has not gone to Armstrong's house personally and ripped the jersey's off the wall. Sounds like something he would do...

Posted

The most surprising thing about that photo is that it's proof that the muppit from USADA has not gone to Armstrong's house personally and ripped the jersey's off the wall. Sounds like something he would do...

 

That I can buy in to.

Posted

Don't know who took the photo.

 

Who could you think of that it wouldn't have been though?

 

Pat McQuaid

Betsy Andreu

Emma O'Riely

Tyler Hamilton

Alberto Contador

Filippo Simeone . . .

Posted

Don't know who took the photo.

 

Who could you think of that it wouldn't have been though?

 

Pat McQuaid

Betsy Andreu

Emma O'Riely

Tyler Hamilton

Alberto Contador

Filippo Simeone . . .

 

Christophe Bassons…

Posted

 

 

 

 

As I said , I am not picking a fight, seems you are not happy with that, so let's fight.

 

Did I completely and utterly misunderstand this statement ?

 

"It requires a little bit of planning and a little bit of post production. It is not merely a snap shot that someone pops off."

 

 

I will say it again, for the third time.

The same effect can be achieved with an i-phone.

 

You also assumed, that I assumed you were being negative about Armstrong.

No.

I just find the little essays people are scribbling around him rather amusing.

Guy drops his hat, and we can do a two page essay as to what his motive was behind it, it's laughable.

 

Cool. And I will say for the third time. It takes some planning. If it is taken with an IPhone does not mean it was not planned. Post production means something done after the image was made. Ie stitching a few images together. Because it could be or may have been done on an iPhone does not mean it is not post production. Whole fine art exhibitions are being shot on weaker cameras than the iPhone.

 

I am sure you are brighter, better educated and more knowledgable than me in a whole host of subjects, most subjects even. Photography, the creation of images, the history of photography, interpretation of images and there dissemination is my field. I do not actually care to debate this with you. I was making a comment from my field of expertise thinking perhaps that some people would enjoy that perspective.

 

Apparently not. Armstrong passions got in the way.

Posted

Cool. And I will say for the third time. It takes some planning. If it is taken with an IPhone does not mean it was not planned. Post production means something done after the image was made. Ie stitching a few images together. Because it could be or may have been done on an iPhone does not mean it is not post production. Whole fine art exhibitions are being shot on weaker cameras than the iPhone.

 

I am sure you are brighter, better educated and more knowledgable than me in a whole host of subjects, most subjects even. Photography, the creation of images, the history of photography, interpretation of images and there dissemination is my field. I do not actually care to debate this with you. I was making a comment from my field of expertise thinking perhaps that some people would enjoy that perspective.

 

Apparently not. Armstrong passions got in the way.

 

You are a great and knowledgeable photographer with a host of knowledge that will put me and everyone else here to shame, no doubt.

For the 4th. time, that image can be take with 360 panorama and get uploaded as is.

No post production.

 

"Armstrongs passions got in the way"

 

Not quite wit you.

 

It's quite OK for people to not see your view.

I disagree that the picture was well planned from a technical aspect, I do however agree that Armstrong had a plan.

 

I disagree with your reasoning behind it, but agree with Eldron's comment as it is actually a bit more factual and carries a bit more logic.

 

Simple really.

Posted

What I can tell you as a commercial photographer is that the image is not a snap shot. It is too carefully put together.

 

I say that because the image is a multi shot panorama that has been stitched together using some or other stitching software. It is therefore a carefully considered statement

 

what! please, i can do a a panorama on my s3 quicker and easier than a hipster can do an instagram.

Posted

Big fuss about nothing, LA removed reference to his 7 wins off his twitter profile , surely as douchebag which he is believed to be he did not have to.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout