Car maintenance

[Captain Fastbastard Mayhem]

As a VW golf owner, I am not just talking from anecdotal experience, but new piston rings on 40000 km.

My dad ran a fleet of 1000+ vehicles - and guess what? Toyota was still the cheapest car to maintain. VW and Audi not so much.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's the very description of anecdotal, Stef... 

[stefmeister]

That's the very description of anecdotal, Stef...

Yeah. Technically. But I was referring to my dad's industry experience. For 1000 cars is a rather big sample compared to the average Joe that maybe drives 5 different cars over a 10 year period.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Captain Fastbastard Mayhem]

Yeah. Technically. But I was referring to my dad's industry experience. For 1000 cars is a rather big sample compared to the average Joe that maybe drives 5 different cars over a 10 year period.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That, I agree with. 

[New Landy new life]

That, I agree with. 

 

I also had a bad VW experience where I lost compression on one cylinder at 58K km's on my Vivo.

 

Ended up with a certain Baron's dealer causing worse harm when reassembling the motor and I footed the R20K rebuild bill at Wackers VW as dealer refused to open the motor again after it starting to smoke immediately after they fixed the head where the compression problem was. 

 

Very looong story so won't bore ya'll with details.

[Eddy Gordo]

I also had a bad VW experience where I lost compression on one cylinder at 58K km's on my Vivo.

 

Ended up with a certain Baron's dealer causing worse harm when reassembling the motor and I footed the R20K rebuild bill at Wackers VW as dealer refused to open the motor again after it starting to smoke immediately after they fixed the head where the compression problem was. 

 

Very looong story so won't bore ya'll with details.

ouch!!

[FlashJordan]

I still love the fecking thing, though. So flippin practical. It's also mine, now, so I may as well swallow it and get it running like a peach. Plan to keep it for a very long time. 

Also recently got a Caddy. 2.0 tdi (maxi). "Downgraded" from a luxury SUV and the caddy is soooo much more practical. I will hardly ever need to use a bike rack. Tandem in the back with both wheels on. 2 MTB's and all family of 4's holiday luggage in the back with plenty room to spare. Super fuel efficient and no slouch either. No problems yet but only 30 000kms on the clock.

[Captain Fastbastard Mayhem]

I also had a bad VW experience where I lost compression on one cylinder at 58K km's on my Vivo.

 

Ended up with a certain Baron's dealer causing worse harm when reassembling the motor and I footed the R20K rebuild bill at Wackers VW as dealer refused to open the motor again after it starting to smoke immediately after they fixed the head where the compression problem was. 

 

Very looong story so won't bore ya'll with details.

I remember this one... forced the piston in, causing the oil catch ring to deform and break, correct?

[Grebel]

I still love the fecking thing, though. So flippin practical. It's also mine, now, so I may as well swallow it and get it running like a peach. Plan to keep it for a very long time. 

 

Might be a case of shutting the door after the horse has bolted, but have you considered an aftermarket warranty? They cover up to 300k mileage wise

 

Now before the neigh sayers jump in and tell you they aren't worth the paper they are written on, I have first hand experience with Motormend who paid out just shy of R75k over three years of owning a 2.0Tdi Audi with the BLB engine. Granted they cover mostly the oily bits but there are options available. Ours cost us R8k so a pretty good ROI if you ask me.

 

Just a thought. It's all about risk management after all...

[the nerd]

My citi golf had 300000km.... When i bought it! 

 

*edit

 

Nothing wrong with an *old*  VW, just needs to be maintained! 

[Skylark]

Myles those 1.9tdi engines are awesome as are Caddies in general, worthwhile fixing.

Make sure you use correct oil, preferably fully synthetic.

[Jakalaka]

Myles those 1.9tdi engines are awesome as are Caddies in general, worthwhile fixing.

Make sure you use correct oil, preferably fully synthetic.

Q: If he's got a new cam, shouldn't he be able to use 507 now?

 

Btw: You're the same Skylark as on the 4x4 forum?

[Captain Fastbastard Mayhem]

Q: If he's got a new cam, shouldn't he be able to use 507 now?

 

Btw: You're the same Skylark as on the 4x4 forum?

507 afaik was the new spec oil to replace all TDI oil apart from the v10 & v6... in place of 505.01 IIRC. 

 

So.. yes?

[Kalahari Vegmot]

507 afaik was the new spec oil to replace all TDI oil apart from the v10 & v6... in place of 505.01 IIRC. 

 

So.. yes?

VW PD engines need 505.01 or 506.01 because of additives necessary for the cam's bearings( I think)

 

So 1.9, 2.5 and V10 need 505.01 or 506.01.

 

And the rest needs 507(which is in other respects the better oil)

 

BUT since you changed the cam, maybe the additives(if that's the real reason) isn't required, and then perhaps you could use 507.

 

But to be safe just make sure it gets serviced with 505.01 or 506.01 until someone with proper knowledge can clarify.

[Imploder]

Hey All,

 

This connector in my TDI keeps working loose (2014 Polo). Does anyone know where I can get this "Dog Collar" connector?

 

https://www.kermatdi.com/i-123-pumpe-duse-intake-hose-manifold-connection-fix-bhw-bhw.html

 

 

Thanks

 

 

[Ecko_1]

I've got a 6 year old Golf 6 GTI. 140000km and no major issues.

 

The car is only as reliable as the maintenance and care

[Captain Fastbastard Mayhem]

VW PD engines need 505.01 or 506.01 because of additives necessary for the cam's bearings( I think)

 

So 1.9, 2.5 and V10 need 505.01 or 506.01.

 

And the rest needs 507(which is in other respects the better oil)

 

BUT since you changed the cam, maybe the additives(if that's the real reason) isn't required, and then perhaps you could use 507.

 

But to be safe just make sure it gets serviced with 505.01 or 506.01 until someone with proper knowledge can clarify.

I use the Liqui-moly 5w30 which is both 507 & 505.01 compliant. At R 750 per 5l, though, it's certainly the most expensive oil I've purchased.