Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 51
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

mmmmm I know of one. It is about 18 months old...flyxii if I remember correct.

 

JCmeyerSS's boet's frame...he cracked it last weekend on the spruit doing a gap jamp we suspect. He is an animal though and rides his bikes HARD.

 

He is getting it fixed though...two crackes straight through on both chainstays very close the brake caliper mounts....both sides, same place

 

Yeah Frame is 18 months old and has about 4500km on it.

I have put about 1000km on it and I'm a racey 102kg

My bro has put the rest on and he is 92kg.

The bike gets punished, gap jumps, drop offs and countless endos.

Its done many MTN marathons, trailseeker marathons and weekends in Mankele and Sabie.

 

Here is a pic of the break. Happened on the 5th time he hit gap jump on the spruit between virgin active and Tana rd.

post-16067-0-21305800-1376933728_thumb.jpeg

Posted

I wore my GT I-drive out after only 20 000km. Frame was worn out at BB linkage so I bought a 2nd/h Raleigh which will last for the next 20k km... Dunno where they are made!!

Posted

 

Ok I will bite...

 

Silverback Sierra...cracked below seatclamp

Trek Hi-Fi Pro...cracked right side chain stay

 

Both alu frames...seems my fongkong is doomed from the start

2x Momsen frames with a crack bellow the seatclamp...
Posted

1x look road frame cracked with me, was swapped out no questions asked. I believe it was flown back to the factory as this was the first recorded manufacturer fault on that frame

Posted

1x look road frame cracked with me, was swapped out no questions asked. I believe it was flown back to the factory as this was the first recorded manufacturer fault on that frame

Which frame and where did it crack?
Posted

I also know of 2x Specialized SL frames that were replaced for paint/clear coat cracks.

 

I have paint cracks on my Spez SL2 but warranty only covers 2 years on paint so i can't get a SL4 :( unless i break my SL2, JC you willing to ride my tar bike? :whistling:

Posted

I also know of 2x Specialized SL frames that were replaced for paint/clear coat cracks.

 

I have paint cracks on my Spez SL2 but warranty only covers 2 years on paint so i can't get a SL4 :( unless i break my SL2, JC you willing to ride my tar bike? :whistling:

For you Crinton anytime

Posted

Yeah Frame is 18 months old and has about 4500km on it.

I have put about 1000km on it and I'm a racey 102kg

My bro has put the rest on and he is 92kg.

The bike gets punished, gap jumps, drop offs and countless endos.

Its done many MTN marathons, trailseeker marathons and weekends in Mankele and Sabie.

 

Here is a pic of the break. Happened on the 5th time he hit gap jump on the spruit between virgin active and Tana rd.

I was on that ride, he would have snapped a steel "pos kantoor fiets" he rides like a savage, respect!

I've snapped a Momsen frame, whilst at my current racing weight of 105kg.

Do a search and you will find that all frames can and do break, i am not sure if it is an inditement to the Chinese frames, the real question would be, What is the ratio between Chinarello and bigger brand's frames failing? That is the only way you could make an objective comparrison. I am convinced that the results of the above will surprise us all....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout