Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

In summary: optical HR sensors are s**t and should not be used outside of laboratory conditions. Use a chest strap.

 

I think this is also relative to the person in question and their wrist and how they wear it.

 

I have a heartrate strap and wrist based heartrate for my current watch. If you went through my training logs you wouldn't be able to tell which were wrist and which were strap readings for my running.

 

Ultra running- not having a strap on is a good way to have 1 less potential chafe spot. That being said the strap makes the watch battery last longer. so there are pros and cons either way.

  • Replies 18k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted (edited)

I think this is also relative to the person in question and their wrist and how they wear it.

 

I have a heartrate strap and wrist based heartrate for my current watch. If you went through my training logs you wouldn't be able to tell which were wrist and which were strap readings for my running.

 

Ultra running- not having a strap on is a good way to have 1 less potential chafe spot. That being said the strap makes the watch battery last longer. so there are pros and cons either way.

I have found that with enough lube and if you are relaxed, a strap on doesn't chafe at all, although I have never tried running with one

Edited by Jewbacca
Posted

I think this is also relative to the person in question and their wrist and how they wear it.

 

I have a heartrate strap and wrist based heartrate for my current watch. If you went through my training logs you wouldn't be able to tell which were wrist and which were strap readings for my running.

 

Ultra running- not having a strap on is a good way to have 1 less potential chafe spot. That being said the strap makes the watch battery last longer. so there are pros and cons either way.

 

I was just summarising the link  :whistling:

Posted

I think this is also relative to the person in question and their wrist and how they wear it.

 

I have a heartrate strap and wrist based heartrate for my current watch. If you went through my training logs you wouldn't be able to tell which were wrist and which were strap readings for my running.

 

Ultra running- not having a strap on is a good way to have 1 less potential chafe spot. That being said the strap makes the watch battery last longer. so there are pros and cons either way.

 

also, not all optical straps are equal.

I find the ones that strap around your arm are great, if I wear a chest strap and my optical polar arm band at the same time the readings are pretty much identical

Posted

I have found that with enough lube and if you are relaxed, a strap on doesn't chafe at all, although I have never tried running with one

bwhahahaha

Posted

I moved from a chest strap to a dedicated optical one on my arm and the difference has been noticeable. The chest strap was inconsistent and battled in cooler winter mornings. My average was much higher with the cheat strap compared with my arm one. The arm HR being closer to what I would expect to see. Maybe I just needed to replace my Garmin unit because I tried a new strap. All that said...I have replaced a chafe on my chest with an odd suntan on my Arm

Posted

Camille Herron is doing what she does best this weekend. 48 hour race, aiming for Americans men's record of 262 miles.

 

She's done 110 in almost 19 hours so far.

Posted

Camille Herron is doing what she does best this weekend. 48 hour race, aiming for Americans men's record of 262 miles.

 

She's done 110 in almost 19 hours so far.

Equally often I seem to write dnf during her effort...

 

Sigh.

 

That run by Sara Hall more than made up for it, wow

Posted

What was the drama?

Eluid Kipchoge came in 7th or 8th... Well off the mark. He says he had a blocked ear from 25km which is going to mess with you balance. Classic symptom of not aclimatising from high altitude to low altitude

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout