Jump to content

#4 EVERESTING 4 DAYS, WORLD RECORD ATTEMPT! #1 @BAINES & @OU KAAPS. #2 CHARITIES.


Recommended Posts

Posted

I hate to be the bad guy here, but I'm confused. Why did you stop at 14 laps? All of the calculations beforehand showed that you'd need to do 20 laps to get to the Everest total. Unfortunately no amount of Strava elevation fixing is going to add the missing 2400m needed. Your Strava ride is pretty close in terms of true elevation gain.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but it's a big ride, not an Everest one.

Agh man that’s a pity

I’m sure Frail will give it another go some time soon...

  • Replies 559
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

I hate to be the bad guy here, but I'm confused. Why did you stop at 14 laps? All of the calculations beforehand showed that you'd need to do 20 laps to get to the Everest total. Unfortunately no amount of Strava elevation fixing is going to add the missing 2400m needed. Your Strava ride is pretty close in terms of true elevation gain.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but it's a big ride, not an Everest one.

I am also confused... Great ride either way, for a good cause.
Posted

I dont know how correct this INFO is.

According to the "EVEREST CALCULATOR".

 

Proper Bainskloof, Wellington WC South Africa
View on Strava » LAPS & DISTANCE

Total Laps 8.7 Lap Distance. 24.8 km, Total Distance 216.9 km

ELEVATION INFO

Total Lap Gain 1012 m Avg. Gradient 3.4%
Ascent Gain 719 m

 

I got led to believe as to the "Everest calculator" I had ridden more than enough to reach an Everest elevation.

Not sure if it might have anything to do with me Recording my ride on a Phone.

Posted

I dont know how correct this INFO is.

According to the "EVEREST CALCULATOR".

 

Proper Bainskloof, Wellington WC South Africa

View on Strava » LAPS & DISTANCE

Total Laps 8.7 Lap Distance. 24.8 km, Total Distance 216.9 km

ELEVATION INFO

Total Lap Gain 1012 m Avg. Gradient 3.4%

Ascent Gain 719 m

 

I got led to believe as to the "Everest calculator" I had ridden more than enough to reach an Everest elevation.

Not sure if it might have anything to do with me Recording my ride on a Phone.

Hi David,

 

My utmost respect for the work you do and I will always wish you well, but the top of Bainskloof is 594m above sea level and you start at about 150m approx, so something seems wrong somewhere.

 

12.4km at 3.4% is also 420m of climbing.

 

Hope I am horribly wrong though!

 

Good luck.

Posted

I hate to be the bad guy here, but I'm confused.  Why did you stop at 14 laps?  All of the calculations beforehand showed that you'd need to do 20 laps to get to the Everest total.  Unfortunately no amount of Strava elevation fixing is going to add the missing 2400m needed.  Your Strava ride is pretty close in terms of true elevation gain.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but it's a big ride, not an Everest one.

exactly what I thought as well.

Posted

I dont know how correct this INFO is.

According to the "EVEREST CALCULATOR".

 

Proper Bainskloof, Wellington WC South Africa

View on Strava » LAPS & DISTANCE

Total Laps 8.7 Lap Distance. 24.8 km, Total Distance 216.9 km

ELEVATION INFO

Total Lap Gain 1012 m Avg. Gradient 3.4%

Ascent Gain 719 m

 

I got led to believe as to the "Everest calculator" I had ridden more than enough to reach an Everest elevation.

Not sure if it might have anything to do with me Recording my ride on a Phone.

The phone does not have a Barometric altimeter and merely relies on Strava data.

 

 

Posted

I hate to be the bad guy here, but I'm confused.  Why did you stop at 14 laps?  All of the calculations beforehand showed that you'd need to do 20 laps to get to the Everest total.  Unfortunately no amount of Strava elevation fixing is going to add the missing 2400m needed.  Your Strava ride is pretty close in terms of true elevation gain.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but it's a big ride, not an Everest one. 

Where do you find that it needs 20 laps?? Go to the everesting calculator and you will see 

Posted

 

Ahh.... I think I see.

 

OK so there are a handful of bainskloof segments on strava. I believe that this is the one that you used:

post-55232-0-37281100-1556538726_thumb.jpg

https://www.strava.com/segments/4263558

It has quite a "sawtooth" profile. Lots of ups and downs along the way that probably aren't there. I think this happens when the person who recorded the segment first had a bit of a dodgy GPS and it was trying to interpolate between contours etc. All those ups and downs add up over each lap and give you an incorrect elevation value.

If you punch the ID of this segment into the everest calculator you get:

post-55232-0-43086600-1556538780_thumb.jpg

Which I suspect is what you were aiming for. 

 

If you add an almost identical segment (except that it is smooth) into the everest calculator, you get:

post-55232-0-12027700-1556538927_thumb.jpg

https://www.strava.com/segments/907329

 

So that is pretty unfortunate. Well done anyway, it's something I'm pretty sure I wouldn't be able to do. And I'm younger than you. 

Posted

Where do you find that it needs 20 laps?? Go to the everesting calculator and you will see 

 

I think Paul confused some of us .. well ME ...

 

Paul repeatedly spoke of "24 hours 24 laps", then stated it would take 22 laps to cover the elevation .... maybe he had a shorter lap in mind at the time ?

 

 

 

Either way, MAMOTH effort !!  Absolute RESPECT !!

Posted

Where do you find that it needs 20 laps?? Go to the everesting calculator and you will see 

 

As I mentioned when I posted about the Everesting Calculator initially, the info it provides needs to be taken with a pinch of salt.  It might be ok out somewhere with a hill and no other terrain around, but with our mountains it has a problem.  It shows the road traversing up and down the Google gradient map while it snakes upwards.  This creates vastly inaccurate route profile and therefore can't be used as a sole "outcome generator".  

The best way is to use the data captured from actual rides.  David did this and calculated 20 laps to get the Everest and 22 laps to get the HRS (http://highrouleur.cc/what/). 

What I don't understand is why he reverted back to the Everesting Calculator instead of the hard data which he had to hand. 

Posted

Maths would suggest the following :

 

Eversting height required : 8848m

 

Height per lap of Bainskloof : 429m (depending on exact start and finish points)

 

Thus 20,6 laps, add the bonus lap FRAIL was talking about and you get the 22 laps he spoke about in line one of post 1.

 

 

If anything, this just re-affirms what it takes to do an Everesting run !!  I dont know any people that can grind out the miles like Paul can, and he fell short of his target.

 

 

EDIT - thought FRAIL's name was Paul from other posts .... corrected this above.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout