Vetplant Posted July 5, 2022 Share @justinafrika raised a point about Ethics in support a sports team. Let's discuss it here. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mikkelz Posted July 5, 2022 Share How about sharing the point that was made, so this thread has some context. 🤔 Otherwise... 🍿 Danger Dassie, mecheng89 and Sid the Sloth 2 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
milky4130 Posted July 5, 2022 Share As in you are the backup vehicle driver and you tow your dropped rider back into contention? mecheng89 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vetplant Posted July 5, 2022 Share 7 minutes ago, mikkelz said: How about sharing the point that was made, so this thread has some context. 🤔 Otherwise... 🍿 @justinafrika, would you mind making the opening statement? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vetplant Posted July 5, 2022 Share 1 minute ago, Vetplant said: @justinafrika, would you mind making the opening statement? In the meantime, here is the link to the original point: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Zebra Posted July 5, 2022 Share I’ll bite: you ended your post ‘just asking’ so here is ‘just replying’… I felt your post WAS provocative/misplaced/likely to derail the topic in the other thread, so happy it has been moved to here… 1. conflating a country’s human right record with that specific thread on the TdF, and the UAE Team in particular, is a bit rich, my opinion… You are conflating government, and cycling… 2. Russia? human rights violations, USA; not much better; fact is, the rapidly ‘Westernizing’ UAE is likely to gradually move towards more-accepted Intl ‘norms’, and even sponsoring an Intl cycling team exposes them to different cultures/races/religions…which can only be a good thing, surely… 3. I spent 3 years in USA, and 3 years in Saudi, and much time in UAE ; in truth, they ALL have serious ‘problems’. Exposure to the globe/different viewpoints/different nationalities, can only be a good thing.the Kashogi murder was tragic/unforgivable, but that is Saudi, and not the UAE… Being highly principled is an admirable trait; potentially derailing the other cycling thread, not so much, again, my5c. Cheers Chris Fred van Vlaanderen, Vetplant, DieselnDust and 1 other 2 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
justinafrika Posted July 6, 2022 Share 17 hours ago, Zebra said: I’ll bite: you ended your post ‘just asking’ so here is ‘just replying’… I felt your post WAS provocative/misplaced/likely to derail the topic in the other thread, so happy it has been moved to here… 1. conflating a country’s human right record with that specific thread on the TdF, and the UAE Team in particular, is a bit rich, my opinion… You are conflating government, and cycling… 2. Russia? human rights violations, USA; not much better; fact is, the rapidly ‘Westernizing’ UAE is likely to gradually move towards more-accepted Intl ‘norms’, and even sponsoring an Intl cycling team exposes them to different cultures/races/religions…which can only be a good thing, surely… 3. I spent 3 years in USA, and 3 years in Saudi, and much time in UAE ; in truth, they ALL have serious ‘problems’. Exposure to the globe/different viewpoints/different nationalities, can only be a good thing.the Kashogi murder was tragic/unforgivable, but that is Saudi, and not the UAE… Being highly principled is an admirable trait; potentially derailing the other cycling thread, not so much, again, my5c. Cheers Chris Yeah thanks Chris. Just got back from an overnight ride so this is my first look. Am a little surprised to read that there’s a consideration that that thread might be derailed ‘cos it's related to a TdF team, I deferred and stepped back at any rate. I guess the question was also elicited in part ‘cos I chose to turn down a World Cup-related job offer in Qatar last year despite a significant personal and professional and financial slump these last several years. Some kinda “personal code” prevented me from working with several of my former graduates in Qatar, given the widespread abuses and shockingly high number of labour-related deaths (6 500) in preparation of the FIFA world cup. I really am interested in the opinions in the bikehub community. Regarding your point 1. about TeamUAE the idea that international sport and politics are separate entities is no more than a myth, since the origins of international sport it has ALWAYS been political. Even the Olympics have always been political. Are we to ignore the massive and widespread abuses of the kafala labour system (especially since 90% of labourers are foreigners with no rights), the forced disappearances of very large numbers of anyone who even even vaguely comments on reforms whether in private or on social media, the legal and formalised assault of wives and daughters? Heck, even the supreme leader al-Maktoum is notorious for the vicious assaults and detention without trial of his wife and daughters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_the_United_Arab_Emirates In fact, Amnesty International’s description of “serious human rights violations, widespread arbitrary detentions, cruel and inhumane treatment of detainees, systemic suppression of freedom of expression…” sounds just like this “white boy from the suburbs’” observations of working in New Brighton and KwaZakhele at the height of the anti-apartheid struggle in the mid 1980’s. Those words describe the apartheid police state. At any rate, the original question came during a lull in action in yesterday’s stage and was directly related to my admiration for Pogačar and his team’s achievements. As for "You are conflating government, and cycling…”, team ownership does in fact go back to Emirati government ownership through two state banks and Emirates Airlines and I was wondering if that would factor into those in the bikehub community’s team/work considerations. Appreciate your opinion and you taking the time to respond, Chris. 👐 Edit: It’s turned into a glorious day here so I’ll check back here after a lunchtime ride through the valley trails. Edited July 6, 2022 by justinafrika Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Titleist Posted July 6, 2022 Share I'm 99% sure that if one boycott a team because of some kind of political issue or whatever, the TDF or any sport for that matter won't take place. No-one is 100% clean. If you find a team that is clean, then you go to the equipment, is that is clean, next up is the staff. If they are clean then next up are the other sponsors. Eventually someone will pop up dirty and then it's on to the next one. Fred van Vlaanderen, DieselnDust and Vetplant 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
justinafrika Posted July 6, 2022 Share 50 minutes ago, Titleist said: I'm 99% sure that if one boycott a team because of some kind of political issue or whatever, the TDF or any sport for that matter won't take place. No-one is 100% clean. If you find a team that is clean, then you go to the equipment, is that is clean, next up is the staff. If they are clean then next up are the other sponsors. Eventually someone will pop up dirty and then it's on to the next one. A bit of a difference between working with a not-“clean” team/company and a team/company owned by those notorious for gross human rights criminality, wouldn’t one think? I guess that’s not a consideration for you, each to their own. I’ve met a couple of gang bosses (and Zuma) over the years if you’re ever desperate for work…. 😁 😂 🙈 I’ll see meself out. Edit: Banter Edited July 6, 2022 by justinafrika Fred van Vlaanderen 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DieselnDust Posted July 6, 2022 Share 47 minutes ago, Titleist said: I'm 99% sure that if one boycott a team because of some kind of political issue or whatever, the TDF or any sport for that matter won't take place. No-one is 100% clean. If you find a team that is clean, then you go to the equipment, is that is clean, next up is the staff. If they are clean then next up are the other sponsors. Eventually someone will pop up dirty and then it's on to the next one. This is my point. Is the lack of ethics confined to human rights violations and then how far back are we going here? our beloved team Qhubheka may be in trouble too with the merc three pointed star on the kit…. this topic requires careful and considered framing <off to smoke a zol before the stage starts> Vetplant 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
M L Posted July 6, 2022 Share 1 hour ago, Titleist said: I'm 99% sure that if one boycott a team because of some kind of political issue or whatever, the TDF or any sport for that matter won't take place. No-one is 100% clean. If you find a team that is clean, then you go to the equipment, is that is clean, next up is the staff. If they are clean then next up are the other sponsors. Eventually someone will pop up dirty and then it's on to the next one. I get what @justinafrika is saying. And it's difficult to be a completely fair judge and juror when it comes to our personal convictions on who to support and and do business with. Personally, I don' like the argument about no one is 100% clean so we might as well support everyone. I think it leads to less accountability and that's never a good thing. How far back in history do you go, what falls within your conviction? I don't know.. I don't give money to beggars. My experience with them is that 90% of beggars have some form of addiction and/or are too lazy to work. So by giving money I most likely support industries in our country, I most definitely don't want to support. And giving food creates a dependency on handouts. Not caring and ignoring the issue is however also not a good solution. So I rather donate to NGOs who I think are addressing these types of problems closer to their roots (foster homes, early childhood development, education, sport programmes, etc), instead of the symptoms. I know I'm not doing it 100% efficiently, and my reasoning isn't 100% rational but that shouldn't stop us from trying. Edited July 6, 2022 by M L typo DieselnDust, justinafrika, Danger Dassie and 1 other 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rowl Posted July 6, 2022 Share Very interesting podcast by The BBC on football and the impact of sportwashing (the below link is on the Pocketcast app: BBC Billionaire Ball Game BBC direct link: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3ct41wd Nestle and all their shenanigans are also a good example of where do you draw the line. Agree with ML's post above. We hold our politicians, family members and the like accountable, why not who we support etc. Vlasov riders under a white flag/no flag. But it comes down to all those dollars/pounds/randelas flowing around. Edited July 6, 2022 by Roul Additional text Fred van Vlaanderen, DieselnDust, Vetplant and 1 other 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mecheng89 Posted July 6, 2022 Share 2 hours ago, Titleist said: I'm 99% sure that if one boycott a team because of some kind of political issue or whatever, the TDF or any sport for that matter won't take place. No-one is 100% clean. If you find a team that is clean, then you go to the equipment, is that is clean, next up is the staff. If they are clean then next up are the other sponsors. Eventually someone will pop up dirty and then it's on to the next one. Ditto for F1. Dodgy AF there as well. Vetplant and DieselnDust 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
M L Posted July 6, 2022 Share 52 minutes ago, Roul said: Very interesting podcast by The BBC on football and the impact of sportwashing (the below link is on the Pocketcast app: BBC Billionaire Ball Game BBC direct link: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3ct41wd Nestle and all their shenanigans are also a good example of where do you draw the line. Agree with ML's post above. We hold our politicians, family members and the like accountable, why not who we support etc. Vlasov riders under a white flag/no flag. But it comes down to all those dollars/pounds/randelas flowing around. Great find Thought: Will a certain level of involvement in something like sport (owning a football club and supporting a few teams at the TdF), give an unreasonable form of protection to a country/political regime/individual with poor human rights records. justinafrika, Rowl and Vetplant 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vetplant Posted July 6, 2022 Share 1 minute ago, mecheng89 said: Ditto for F1. Dodgy AF there as well. Another example: A gripe I can raise is the societal damage that alcohol does to our society at-large. This gripe is rooted in personal experiences of lives in our family that were ruined due to alcohol. So, do I have merit to boycott any sports team that is sponsored by Castle/SAB? Can I force other people to see things my way and boycott them too? Very difficult thing to pin down. I think if your own convictions push you to avoid a team/sport due to atrocities, then do it. But don't expect others to follow you on your path. IMHO. Zebra, justinafrika, M L and 1 other 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
J Wakefield Posted July 6, 2022 Share Lets just make sure we get the teams names correct for sakes of the thread: For starters it is UAE Team Emirates. TheoG, Vetplant, justinafrika and 4 others 3 1 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now