Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

No, I'm not asking you to stop, we should interrogate people's arguments it's what's makes for constructive debate, I truly am not worked up ;) Well I wouldn't be if we interrogated my statement that "people's times up hills is a bad measurement of comparable performance" but instead we focused on me saying "it's accepted.....".

 

I stand by my statement that "individual isolated times up hills is not an accurate way to determine performance capabilities between athletes because of all the variables that can influence the end result", and I'm not saying this because it the general consensus :)

 

Maybe we should start a new thread about it if we want to interrogate that method further :)

What I will try to stop is being a dick! It is that which I am sorry 'bout :oops:  :thumbup: .

  • Replies 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

I think with this many replies  and this subject matter it's time to turn the clock back and get ready for a for a good, honest, old fashioned, friday hub special... come on, those pitch forks and lanterns have been hiding away for far too long. :)

 

http://coolerinsights.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/angry-mob.jpeg

 

Statement released on a monday, then twitter goes down on Tuesday... hmmm seems like the powers that be did not want this thread getting to Friday. 

Posted

Exactly this.

 

Who are Vets... 30 to 50 year olds who mostly can afford R100k bikes, most are competitive hence them racing.

 

Risk is also lower, as getting caught won't affect salary earning ability.

 

I would love it if they tested more Vets!

EPO is cheap too... less than my monthly coffee bill... #justsaying.... actually its about the same - but I choose coffee... tastes better.

 

Anyone who can afford a 6 figure bike can fund an epo habit pretty easily if they can get a script - in fact their medical aid might well pay for it too.

Posted

EPO is cheap too... less than my monthly coffee bill... #justsaying.... actually its about the same - but I choose coffee... tastes better.

Anyone who can afford a 6 figure bike can fund an epo habit pretty easily if they can get a script - in fact their medical aid might well pay for it too.

If only the hub had some Drs
Posted

Old Ross Tucker is not letting up on poor Tumbleweed's bro!

Ross Tucker@Scienceofsport 25m25 minutes ago

@katjanechild @KevinMcCallum the discrepancy in the dates was obvious within minutes.You often seek 3rd opinion on your stories. Not onerous

 

Although tbh it seems to be a case of shooting the messenger because he doesn't like the explanations!

Tumbles brother newds to do some homework on ozone therapy and ts acceptance in conventional medicine... I thought KE had just made a typo and he was referring to the blood transfusions - I should pay closer attention sometimes - my BS alarm should go off faster.
Posted

Sorry - I differ on this - scientist do agree that measured performance does predict performance capability

I agree with you that measured performance does predict capabilities. But measured against a set of constants. You need to limit the variables to increase accuracy of the measurement.

 

Also, people mustn't now go and assume that I'm claiming that there is no merit in climb comparisons, but if you want to measure climb comparisons you need to take the variables into account.

 

Eg. If Froome climbed Ventoux in 45mins in 2015 during the Tour and again climbed it in 45mins at a training camp in 2016, you cannot with certainty say that his capabilities were identical in both attempts based purely on ascent times. You have to take other factors into consideration.

Posted

EPO is cheap too... less than my monthly coffee bill... #justsaying.... actually its about the same - but I choose coffee... tastes better.

 

Anyone who can afford a 6 figure bike can fund an epo habit pretty easily if they can get a script - in fact their medical aid might well pay for it too.

Cheap is relative. Most South Aftican Pro cyclists probably couldn't afford your monthly coffee bill. Most white collar professionals aged 30-50 (Vets) probably could.

 

Also the risk, if you get caught using HGH at a race, you wouldn't lose your medical license, pro cyclists would.

 

Surely it's not hard to see that the barrier to entry and risks is lower for Vets to dope. Again not saying that they do, but that's it's just less off a mission for them too if they choose to do so. They also have less incentive to do so, it's only competitive nature that drives them, not a need to maintain their jobs, so it's not all against them :)

Posted

Yes. More practical & realistic to allow all competitors to use whatever they like. Some will kill themselves doing it - like Simpson did. But I suspect genetics & appropriate training will still prevail over any chemical advantage - we don't know, because we're still bickering about moral issues

Are you saying we should do away with any and all forms of morality?
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout