Jump to content

2019 Trek Madone SL6 disc vs 2021 Cannondale SystemSix


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 142
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

I would go Cannondale if I had to choose either but I also wouldn't buy a new bike that weighs over 8.5kg. That's what bikes weighed 20 years ago. For that kind of money I want it <6.5kg

Posted

I would go Cannondale if I had to choose either but I also wouldn't buy a new bike that weighs over 8.5kg. That's what bikes weighed 20 years ago. For that kind of money I want it <6.5kg

 

would not listen to this. very old way of thinking.

now days the aero gains far outweigh weight penalties. 

 

there are enough studies out there to verify this -> google is your friend.

 

i'd take a heavier aero bike any day of the week over a lightweight non-aero bike.

 

RSA has very few races with long climbs or extremely steep climbs where weight will have a massive impact.

our shorter punchier climbs are purpose built for a aero build and even if the get steep its never for a long period of time

Posted

would not listen to this. very old way of thinking.

now days the aero gains far outweigh weight penalties. 

 

there are enough studies out there to verify this -> google is your friend.

 

i'd take a heavier aero bike any day of the week over a lightweight non-aero bike.

 

RSA has very few races with long climbs or extremely steep climbs where weight will have a massive impact.

our shorter punchier climbs are purpose built for a aero build and even if the get steep its never for a long period of time

 

Mitigated by the fact that most races in SA are group events not TTs and you will spend most of your time in a group which nullifies the aero gains.

 

Weight, aero, blah blah blah - the truth is that most riders are not in the category where one or the other will make a meaningful difference to your race time/training speed.

 

Buy the bike that you like the most and will feel coolest riding. 

Posted

I would go Cannondale if I had to choose either but I also wouldn't buy a new bike that weighs over 8.5kg. That's what bikes weighed 20 years ago. For that kind of money I want it <6.5kg

Aero gains trump weight gains up to a gradient of 7%.

 

Lighter isn’t always faster.

Posted

Mitigated by the fact that most races in SA are group events not TTs and you will spend most of your time in a group which nullifies the aero gains.

 

Weight, aero, blah blah blah - the truth is that most riders are not in the category where one or the other will make a meaningful difference to your race time/training speed.

 

Buy the bike that you like the most and will feel coolest riding. 

 

 

Riding in a group doesn't nullify aero gains. Unless you sitting 8th wheel all day everyday what about riding across a split maybe or just going down hill. These modern aero bikes are slippery.

 

Posted

Riding in a group doesn't nullify aero gains. Unless you sitting 8th wheel all day everyday what about riding across a split maybe or just going down hill. These modern aero bikes are slippery.

 

 

or if you find yourself riding in the gutter or on the leading edge of a cross wind

Posted

Riding in a group doesn't nullify aero gains. Unless you sitting 8th wheel all day everyday what about riding across a split maybe or just going down hill. These modern aero bikes are slippery.

 

 

Sitting behind one person offers around a 30% saving in wind resistance.

 

Wind resistance is 75% body and 25% bike.

 

 

They may be slippery as hell but they're only responsible for a small fraction of overall wind resistance.

 

A superultra aero bike will reduce your overall wind a few % at most. 

Posted

Aero gains trump weight gains up to a gradient of 7%.

 

Lighter isn’t always faster.

 

Bearing in mind you're going a minimum speed where you can actually take advantage of the aero benefit.

 

Aero isn't always faster.

Posted

Bearing in mind you're going a minimum speed where you can actually take advantage of the aero benefit.

 

Aero isn't always faster.

Wait you guys don't ride at 42kph? To save 5 watts an hour blah blah blah #Amateurs
Posted

Riding in a group doesn't nullify aero gains. Unless you sitting 8th wheel all day everyday what about riding across a split maybe or just going down hill. These modern aero bikes are slippery.

 

I road a new generation aero bike with 60mm deep wheels.I hated descending in the wind with it or having trucks come past me.They might be slippery from the front but side winds are nerve wrecking.Would hate to own one in PE or Cape Town[emoji15]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Settings My Forum Content My Followed Content Forum Settings Ad Messages My Ads My Favourites My Saved Alerts My Pay Deals Help Logout