JBK Posted July 8 Share My opinion on this is that some people have all their notification settings switched off and they don't list their telephone numbers so they simply do not receive the messages requesting info or offers to purchase. I wanted to buy a saddle from someone and sent about 5 messages over the course of about 8 or 9 days asking for them to please make contact so that I could buy the saddle. I wasn't going to negotiate or anything. Eventually I got so the hell in that I offered them half - thinking that will maybe get their attention. They replied a few days later that it was sold. Pity that you cant review someone with whom you did not buy something from. Edited July 8 by JBK Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cadenceblur Posted July 8 Share 12 minutes ago, JBK said: My opinion on this is that some people have all their notification settings switched off and they don't list their telephone numbers so they simply do not receive the messages requesting info or offers to purchase. I wanted to buy a saddle from someone and sent about 5 messages over the course of about 8 or 9 days asking for them to please make contact so that I could buy the saddle. I wasn't going to negotiate or anything. Eventually I got so the hell in that I offered them half - thinking that will maybe get their attention. They replied a few days later that it was sold. Pity that you cant review someone with whom you did not buy something from. You can review someone without a purchase. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rampies Posted July 8 Share 28 minutes ago, cadenceblur said: You can review someone without a purchase. Can I also switch off the reviews I resolved ("don't like") to give a true impression ("fake") my review stats? I read it is quite commonplace nowadays with cycling gear. PS. Definitely a slow work day - 3 posts! I might be losing my job soon, but hey, I only have 77 more posts to go! Edited July 8 by rampies clarified: 77 more posts hansolo and JBK 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JBK Posted July 8 Share 32 minutes ago, cadenceblur said: You can review someone without a purchase. that's new - and that's the answer - just go and give bad reviews - might shake them up Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cadenceblur Posted July 8 Share 24 minutes ago, JBK said: that's new - and that's the answer - just go and give bad reviews - might shake them up I’ve just reviewed a rude time waster now . Edited July 8 by cadenceblur Spelling Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hairy Posted July 8 Share 21 hours ago, Mountain Bru said: What would really make the classifieds next level amazing would be if you could select an option in your profile to only sell to guys with a certain number of forum posts, and only buy from guys with a certain number of forum posts, and if turning that on somehow brought back comments on the classifieds 🤩🤩🤩 Interesting point ... if at the time of generating the add, the seller can select if they want to allow or disallow comments. MORNE and ChrisF 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vaultboy Posted July 8 Share 28 minutes ago, JBK said: that's new - and that's the answer - just go and give bad reviews - might shake them up Seems like a recipe for reviewbombing. I would prefer to only be able to review after bona fide sales. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Matt Posted July 8 Share 1 hour ago, JBK said: … Pity that you cant review someone with whom you did not buy something from. 1 hour ago, cadenceblur said: You can review someone without a purchase. This is incorrect. Yes, technically possible to post a review but it’s against our Review policy: https://help.bikehub.co.za/en/articles/5778178-user-review-policy Reviews may only be added where a sale happened or a firm agreement was in place As per our Terms of service: User reviews should only be submitted where an agreement to transact exists or a transaction was concluded on Bike Hub. We reserve the right to remove feedback that relates to negotiations or communications where there was no agreement and/or a transaction did not take place or relates to a transaction not initiated via Bike Hub. In short, if a sale wasn't concluded or there was no agreement to sell in place you should not be posting a review. If this cannot be verified we may prevent you from posting a review or remove a review. Vaultboy 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
shaper Posted July 8 Share 1 hour ago, cadenceblur said: You can review someone without a purchase. Edit: I see Matt posted the same Maybe you should read bikehubs FAQ/Help centre This has been discussed many times over the years, reviewing without purchasing opens it up to abuse for many reasons, no responses like you get, missed out on a deal or just didn't like the tone.... Reviews may only be added where a sale happened or a firm agreement was in place https://help.bikehub.co.za/en/articles/5778178-user-review-policy Edited July 8 by shaper Matt 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
babse Posted July 8 Share 30 minutes ago, Hairy said: Interesting point ... if at the time of generating the add, the seller can select if they want to allow or disallow comments. dibs Hairy and MORNE 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cadenceblur Posted July 8 Share Okay, so the bad behavior will just continue then. Good luck to the others that come across these individuals then. May they continue with impunity! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MORNE Posted July 8 Share 1 hour ago, rampies said: Can I also switch off the reviews I resolved ("don't like") to give a true impression ("fake") my review stats? I read it is quite commonplace nowadays with cycling gear. PS. Definitely a slow work day - 3 posts! I might be losing my job soon, but hey, I only have 77 more posts to go! Noob…you should have made your edit a new post all together👀 rampies 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MORNE Posted July 8 Share 44 minutes ago, Hairy said: Interesting point ... if at the time of generating the add, the seller can select if they want to allow or disallow comments. I Mountain Bru 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Matt Posted July 8 Share 38 minutes ago, cadenceblur said: Okay, so the bad behavior will just continue then. Good luck to the others that come across these individuals then. May they continue with impunity! Unfortunately as far as reviews are concerned a line has to be drawn somewhere. You'll find our policy is similar to many other platforms. As others have noted, if it's left totally open there's far too much room for abuse and subjectivity... and then the whole thing falls apart. We have considered other means to encourage & highlight positive behaviour. And, would welcome any fresh ideas. For example, those who respond to messages within X number of hours/days get a "Responds quickly" badge. That doesn't solve for the time wasters, but at least surfaces those who are unlikely to waste time. mazambaan and Kyle_Hanger 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BaGearA Posted July 8 Share 44 minutes ago, cadenceblur said: Okay, so the bad behavior will just continue then. Good luck to the others that come across these individuals then. May they continue with impunity! Again not Bikehub ....people Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
betaboy Posted July 8 Share 19 hours ago, ACE Cycles said: Coming from someone that sold on this platform for a living, those you speak of spend more time talking k@k and stroking their fragile egos than they do in actually buying anything There are 2 kinds of hubbers, those that do, and those that talk …Eish, talk about taking that KOM! 😅 MORNE and JBK 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now