Steven Holmes Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 (edited) Two wholesalers in bicycle price-fixing charges get R4m administrative fines each - 31 March 2016 Today, Tuesday 31 May, the Tribunal has issued both its order and its reasons in the Omnico and Coolheat Cycle case. It has awarded an administrative penalty to Omnico of R4627412 and to Coolheat Cycles a penalty of R4250612. The Tribunal has already confirmed six consent orders by wholesalers and 11 retailers in the bicycle sector who were implicated in a price-fixing investigation by the Competition Commission. The two wholesalers, Omnico and Coolheat, however, chose to oppose the charges and the matter was heard last year by the Tribunal. The Commission relied for its case primarily on a meeting held on 10 September 2008 where about 200 bicycle wholesalers and retailers attended a meeting at Midrand Conference Centre in Gauteng to discuss increasing their markup on bicycles to 50% from 35%, and the markup on cycling accessories to 75% from 50%. The wholesalers would give the retailers a higher mark-up by increasing the Recommended Retail Price to consumers. Prices to consumers would be increased so that retailers could make higher margins. Prices were set to increase on 1 October 2008, as it was the beginning of the new cycling season and new bicycles and accessories were usually launched at this time and new price lists issued. Details of these discussions had been posted on an online discussion forum called The Hub and was brought to the attention of the Commission. Evidence presented at the hearing revealed that both Omnico and Coolheat had attended the September meeting that there was agreement among wholesalers to increase the mark-up on wholesale prices for bicycles and cycling accessories in co-ordination. In determining the penalties the Tribunal took into account some mitigating factors for Omnico. However, it found no such mitigating factors for Coolheat, who had elected not to give evidence at the Tribunal and to explain its subsequent price increases. The other 17 companies who settled early with the Commission were not fined for the offence as they had admitted they had contravened section 4(1)(b) of the Competition Act. The Commission had withdrawn its case against one of the companies, Fritz Pienaar Cycles, because the business was liquidated. Issued by:Chantelle BenjaminCommunications: Competition Tribunal --- Omnico’s official statement on this matter1 June 2016 “Four years ago the Competition Commission commenced legal proceedings against a number of wholesalers and retailers contending that they were guilty of price fixing. 17 consent orders were obtained by the Commission ( ie these parties agreed to admitting guilt) and no fine was imposed on them. Omnico and another party denied any contravention as alleged by the Commission and as such refused to consent to an order as required by the Commission. Had Omnico simply consented, that effectively would have been the end of the matter and no fine would have been imposed on them by the Commission. The matter proceeded and the Competition Tribunal, after a lengthy and expensive legal process has ordered that Omnico contravened the Competition Act and imposed a fine. Omnico is disappointed at the Tribunal’s decision and maintains that it was not party to any anti-competitive agreement as alleged. In the circumstances Omnico has instructed its legal advisors to appeal the Tribunal’s decision.” Edited June 2, 2016 by Admin Added official statement from Omnico Ferro, nonky, NGUTF and 2 others 5
bassasdaindia Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 should make an entertaining thread . ChUkKy and popcorn_skollie 2
Shebeen Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 BOOOOOOM! but, like the bread vibe, i suppose we're going to pay in the end. GLuvsMtb, AdamA, Ferro and 3 others 6
shaper Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 Seems the mark up policy has been implemented since 2008 and continues to do so each year..... ChUkKy and wiledog_x 2
Hairy Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 guess shimano prices are going to go through the roof soon Bizkit031, JXV and ChUkKy 3
Showtime Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 guess shimano prices are going to go through the roof soon I can almost see them approaching SRAM prices KingTJ and Morwa 2
T-Bob Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 guess shimano prices are going to go through the roof soon Their sales are falling this year site badly... but don't worry, they'll go up!
Steven Holmes Posted May 31, 2016 Author Posted May 31, 2016 I think its good. For years these guys have milked us!! With this type of pressure from the Competition Tribunal and the competition from the online guys, prices will be kept in check. Well, as much as they can be anyway. Damn exchange rate!! Gen, Pah Bear and ddj 3
Flemish Lion Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 The R4m x 2 should be distributed to us CONSUMERS! Mongoose!, Cappi, GT Jimmy and 8 others 11
Flemish Lion Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 ?They've been marking up and we paid the higher prices... gummibear 1
davidl Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 Whilst levying the fines is a good thing, it will not have any benefit for us. The retailers are now all hiding behind the exchange rate to increase prices. Nothing really comes our way! EmptyB, raptor-22, wiledog_x and 1 other 4
Hairy Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 They've been marking up and we paid the higher prices...got you .... so now they just hand over the cash owed and then mark up anyway ?
Danger Dassie Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 They've been marking up and we paid the higher prices... The issue was price fixing, not the actual percentage of markup. Flemish Lion, Pah Bear and Hairy 3
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now